Brooklyn Renters: Should You Keep Renting or Buy?
Checklist by Peter Mancini Pen Realty | Member of REBNY & BNYMLS
Use this checklist to make a confident move in today’s Brooklyn real estate market.
Brooklyn Rent or Buy Checklist
1. Assess Your Long-Term Plans
Planning to stay 5+ years? ️ Buying may be the move.
Need flexibility (job, family, travel)? ️ Renting might be smarter.
2. Check Your Finances
Down payment saved? (20% ideal, but 3–5% possible with programs)
Credit score good? Better score = better mortgage rates
Emergency fund in place?
3. Calculate Hidden Costs of Homeownership
Property Taxes
Homeowners Insurance
Maintenance & Repairs ( NYT estimates $3K–$5K/year!)
Closing Costs (2–5% of home price)
4. Research the Market
Mortgage Rates: WSJ & The Real Deal say they're always shifting.
Home Prices: Is it a buyer’s or seller’s market?
Compare: Rental Costs vs. Mortgage Payments
5. Know Your Lifestyle Needs
Want to build equity and settle in? Buy
Value flexibility and fewer responsibilities? Rent
Prefer predictable monthly costs? Rent