Wollongong, Tarana & Rydal

About 7 or 8 years ago I was comparing notes with a country doctor during a round of golf and one of his strong beliefs was to keep active, keep your mind working, keep learning, always try something new and read lots of books. This was pretty normal for me as my study in ‘our house’ is always in a mess with how to books, manuals for everything, photography books, maps, motor vehicles, biographies, history and of course some good fiction writers. So heeding his suggestion I decided to create a new approach by compiling written progressive story about my life, important events, family network, and my working life, especially being a forensic cop. Overall I have had a very interesting life from the way I approached work from the very beginning. Once work started I always looked for opportunities, better ways to do my job and get a better education. I always took responsibility for my actions, was innovative from day one, always finding better ways to do stuff and never taking a backward step. It is our respons- ibility to challenge what is wrong and strive for a system that is just and equitable for all. Born in Wollongong My only knowledge of Wollongong, besides my sisters Karlene and Joan (I do not really remember them back then), is a story Mum told me many years later of course, of an interesting incident that happened in May 1945 at our then home at 41 Jutland Ave, Wollongong. The house had to be reasonably close to shopping as Mum didn’t drive. Obviously it was nearing the end of WWII when I arrived so I guess Mum walked lots as Dad was still winding down his Army service with a stint in the Armoured Division of the Army after his return from North Africa. Dad had worked at Port Kembla Steelworks prior to the war and that is probably why he ended up in the Ar- moured Corps at the end of his service ...... more to go here I guess Mum had to be a walker as she never held a driving licence and owning a motor vehicle in those days was indeed a luxury, at that time anyway. Mum told me when I was about ten months old she left me sitting on the kitchen cupboard, for just a few seconds, and when she turned back there I was sitting on the floor with not a whimper, until she picked me up and I cried like blazes every time she touched my legs. A trip to the doctor suggested a possible hairline fracture of the femur and it would seem
A Story to Remember - 201123
1
from very early on trouble was never far away from me. I recall a family friend or relative living not too far away from us in Wollongong, we called her ‘Quinnie’ and after we left town we visited her whenever we returned to Wollongong, which was many times over the years. Karlene will know this! We must have only lived in Wollongong for a short time although Dad had worked at the steelworks in Wollongong for some time after he was released from his army service, where he worked in the Armoured Division after he returned from army service in the North African Campaign. Mum’s brother George Mansingh owned the general store and butcher at Tarana, which he wanted Dad and Mum to manage, including the butcher’s shop. Apparently Uncle George Mansingh wanted to get into or was already in real estate in Portland. It would appear Dad probably did the butcher shop and Mum ran the general store, it also seemed likely Dad also taught Mum her butchering skills, which came to the fore when she eventually worked the butcher shop at Rydal after we moved there several years later. Mum’s parents Charles & Fanny Louisa Mansingh lived at Tarana Quarries and my mum Ena had one sister Cora and three brothers Arthur, George and Gordon (Pop). - verify this Apparently I was a regular visitor to the Tarana pub across the road from the shop where I used to sit on a stool at the far end of the bar, to converse with the publican Bob Gillett very early in the day, as he prepared for the regulars to arrive. Somehow Bob used to always have something available from the kitchen for me to eat, just to keep me going till lunchtime. Lunch wasn’t at 12:30pm or 1pm in those days, lunch was when you felt hungry. So then it was back across the road to the store to annoy Mum or Dad as I was only about three or four at the time. Often I would be up to Tarana schoolhouse where I would meet up with my mate Tiny Cluely, who was a few years older then me during morning play- time or lunch break. I have been told one day Tiny and I went to the chook house at the Webb property on top of the hill behind the school, grabbed a few live chook’s and tossed them down the pit toilets in the school yard. How we were discovered or who had found the chook’s I know not, but it did happen and to prevent something else happening again the schoolmaster allowed me to start school when I was four and a half years old. The reason being when I wasn’t getting into trouble with Tiny I was pestering the school master to let me come to school. So he caved in and I officially started in January 1949, problem solved. At Tarana Dad used to make regular customer deliveries from the shop in Tarana in his 1930’s something T-Model Ford Ute Regd.No.LX-026 , somehow it’s just the rego number
A Story to Remember - 201123
2
I remember specifically. Sometimes I would go with Dad when he made deliveries to Kate Griffith & Albert at Jerrys Mount where some of Mum’s uncles ( all bachelors ) on the Charlton side of the family, lived. They used to walk to the store from Jerrys Mount, five or six miles , just to get regular provisions. There was Uncle Ike, Joe, Sidney, Horatio, Alfred & Walter who all lived at the mount and never married ( thanks to big sister Karlene for this info ). Well this was the start of my attachment to motor vehicles I guess and it seemed during the following months I got a bit impatient and I took up a bit of vehicle theft (albeit tempor- ary). First to go was a Co-op Bakery lorry parked out front of the general store. The old Co-op Bakers truck was open so I got in the driver’s seat and started playing around with the steering wheel and all the levers, including the handbrake and I must have let the hand handbrake off and the lorry rolled across the road and into the wire fence between the railway station and the road in front of the shop. First hand witness report indicated I said If the bloody fence wasn’t there I’d have been in Bathurst by now”. But wait there’s more; not very long after this incident another careless local driving a rather large four door sedan left his vehicle parked outside the front of the store, no keys but unlocked, easy pickings. So I gave it another go, off with the handbrake and hang onto the steering wheel, this was fun. It was the same ending with that fence getting in the way again and no stories from the rescuers as to any comments by yours truly, it seems that was enough for everybody! I am unaware of the direct results of my theft and capture with regard to punishment, grounding wasn’t around in those days, but maybe there is one chance! Karlie! Major Train Crash April 1950 a railway fireman was killed and the driver seri - ously injured when a petrol tanker on a derailed train blew up, just up the line from Tarana towards Sodwalls. The explosion occurred when a railway embankment, weakened by heavy rain had collapsed and the locomotive, along with several trucks plunged off the railway line. The train was travelling between Tarana and Sodwalls, about 10pm. It was pulling trucks carrying oil, timber, and at least one petrol tanker. I can recall a loud explosion at some stage and later in the morning somebody took me up for a look from nearby paddocks. Probably one of the local farmers from the homestead on the carry all which was attached to the back of a Ferguson tractor. It all seemed too hard to me that the railway gang of fettlers could fix the line, but they did. The next step for our family was after Dad had arranged a job with Arcos at the new Wallerawang Power Station which was being built, however this meant a family move to Rydal, to minimise travel and for uncle George to return and take over the store.
A Story to Remember - 201123
3
Move to Rydal When we first arrived in Rydal around 1950 we were in a house up on the hillside almost directly in line with the railway Crossing, but we only stayed there for a few weeks or months and I don’t recall much at all from that house except for some vague memories of the kitchen being separated from the house by an open covered section, paved with bricks. Not long after we moved across to Charles Street which was on the other side of the railway line and followed Solitary Creek along before crossing the creek and up the hill to King’s place. One more thing to discuss with Karlie! The house in Charles Street was an unpainted old fibro place, externally, with an old fashioned wood stove for cooking, an icebox for keeping food cool, a Donkey and Copper for wash- ing, with a Chip heater to heat up the water for baths. No showers where we lived in those days and the toilet was down the back yard about thirty yards from the back steps. They used sanitary cans in those days which slid under the toilet seat, so when the sanitary cart came each week the driver would slide the full can out and replace it with a clean empty can. The ‘dunny carter’ would sling the full can up on his shoulder to take it out to the cart, which was about a sixty yard walk at Charles street, very little was easy in those days. In order to keep the stove going all day for Mum to cook, cleaning and doing the washing Mum needed plenty of wood. There was also an open fireplace in the lounge room for the winter months. Dad ordered in a load of six ton’s of wood which needed to be split for the stove, he bought a new axe, for me. There were no heating controls on the stove and Mum just knew when the oven or stove top was hot enough, by the way the wood was burning. Dad demonstrated his way of cutting wood to the right size for the stove and the open fire in the lounge room, handed the axe to me and said ‘have a go’. Luckily as it turned out the majority of this first lot had been well cut so not a lot to do except split the wood and make chips from the long stuff for the chip heater. The combined laundry and bath, this comprised of a copper set in brick surrounds and fire bricks around an internal mini-fire pit so a larger quantity of water could boiled for Mum to do the washing. The chip heater was for the bath and was an everyday day job for me to provide hot water in the bath, Karlie & Joan were first, Lynnie and I would be last in that lot of bathwater. A fresh bath for Mum and
A Story to Remember - 201123
4
because she was cooking and sewing late most days she used to keep the chip heater going a bit longer, because she could do stuff or she would boil the copper for some washing and she would use that water to bathe. Every week a very large block of ice would arrive on the train from Bathurst, I would lug the block of ice home, using an ice block handle, from the Railway Station and put it in Mum’s Ice Box which was similar to the fridge freezer we use now. but the ice block went into the top section which was not opened until the next block ar- rived, from Bathurst Ice Works twice a week. We didn’t open the icebox like we do now with a modern fridge, every time we feel like an ice cream or a cold drink, we had to go to the shop, the lid to the icebox remained closed as that’s what kept food cold in the fridge! We couldn’t afford those luxuries at that time. Eventually Dad bought Mum a Figidaire Electric fridge, with a freezer, Mum was very happy, and so was I, with one less job. We were directly across the road from the Hunter (Richard) family, about 100 yards from the Rydal railway station, on the inside of a bend in the road which went on over Solitary Creek and up the hill to the large Kings home which was set back in the bush at the top of the hill. Our house was in a direct line to the Railway station, jump through a wire fence, cross the railway lines, through the station with a quick ‘Hello’ to station master Keith McManus or Greg Featherstone and then across Rydal’s main street to the Public School, easy as one could ask for. The school headmaster was Charlie Gorman who was an older chap, but he was a very good teacher and each year we had visiting student teachers from Bathurst Teachers College for a couple of weeks, so they could practice their teaching skills on us. All the kids looked forward to this change and one or two of us would take the mickey’ as any opportunity arose, it was all good fun in those days. Of course Charles Street where we lived was a gravel road, so up the big hill behind our place, leading up to the King’s property, was the perfect place for billy cart racing. This was when Dad introduced me to building my own stuff, as country kids we didn’t buy or sell billy carts, we made our own unique versions and used then until they fell apart. Once Dad could see I was really interested and making an effort he taught me about the tools I had use and the mechanical issues I needed to know, if the cart was to work properly. We also worked on Dad’s Morris Oxford sedan when it needed a valve grind, carburettor service or replacement radiator - all the good stuff for a kid.
A Story to Remember - 201123
5
I built the billy cart using old timber planks, rear wheels from an old tricycle that was rusted a bit and a couple of smaller pram wheels which I turned up around town and some steering rope. Unfortunately during my demo run for Dad halfway down the hill one of the front wheels fell off, pretty rough axle job on my part and Dad said leave it to me I’ll get a front axle made up so you can steer with your feet! Two days later I had a new axle and some light oil for the wheels, so I put the billycart together and away I went up the hill and back down again, everything went great. Plenty of testing during the weeks that followed paid off but, I still wasn’t quite fast enough to end up in front, Dad noticed that. Again he had another trick up his sleeve and he told me about Goanna Oil but that seemed a bit far fetched to me, he had to be kidding, then true to his word he brought some Goanna Oil home. This was my secret for the big race, take all the wheels off and re-grease the axles before the race, not a word to anyone. Another modification I made was to the rear wheels, one of the solid tyres had come off during testing and this was something I could not replace, so I removed the tyre from the other rear wheel, in the hope that I would get a better grip when taking the sharp right hand bend in the middle of the course. It seemed to be working, rougher ride but the bare wheels really dug in on the bend and I had an advantage, I told the others that Dad was getting some new wheels for me and nobody took any notice. Race day finally arrived and we did held our ‘annual billy cart race’, which always attracted a crowd of local spectators, usually about ten local mothers and fathers. We would race down the old Coach Road from outside the King’s property at the top of the hill, with a sharp right hander in the middle of the run and this was a big problem for some riders, if you were in the first two at the bend you were looking good. The sun hung low in the sky, casting a warm glow over the small town where kids eagerly gathered for the annual billy cart race. The dirt road stretched out before them, down a big hill that promised an exhilarating ride. Excitement buzzed through the air as makeshift carts, cobbled together with bits of wood and old wheels, lined up at the starting point. There were seven or eight starters and all was going to plan, the race began with a flurry of shouts and laughter as the fearless youngsters propelled their carts down the slope. The sound of wheels clattering against the uneven dirt filled the air. As they neared the halfway point, a sharp bend to the right awaited, challenging their skills and daring them to push the limits.
A Story to Remember - 201123
6
In the midst of the chaos, a particular cart, adorned with bright colours and a hand-painted number three, found itself in a surprising position. The crowd gasped as the once third-place contender skilfully navigated the bend and past rivals to seize the coveted first position. Cheers erupted from the sidelines, celebrating the unexpected turn of events. However, the thrill was short-lived. Just as victory seemed within grasp, a sudden problem struck the cart. He was too tight and slowed considerably in the heavy exit loose gravel in the gutter and finished 4th. In the end, despite the early triumph, the spirited Paul had to settle for fourth place. The cheers turned to sympathetic applause as the young driver crossed the finish line, showcasing the unpredictable nature of billy cart racing and the resilience of adventurous kids. The standout mates I can remember, not many in a small town like Rydal, are Peter Gardiner, David Flynn, Billy Wilson, Rodney Arrowsmith, Richard Hunter, Laurie Clements, Allan Piggott, David Brown & me, I am unsure whether or not Andrew Blowes (Mt Lambie) came in to town to compete - Keith Peppernell and his wife were our close neighbours and we just called her ‘Pepp’. Back in those days there were weird people around and although our parents didn’t know about them generally, it was the kids that worked them out and we knew who to keep away from; then we would tell our parents who was who! Occasionally they doubted our opinion us or just indicate ‘they couldn’t beieve it’, so we let those ones go through to the keeper, but we made sure all the other kids knew! Alongside the railway line out towards Wallerawang a mile or two a friendly old guy had a small eucalyptus plantation where he extracted the oil, which very (slow process) and then sold it on to whoever wanted the oil. As kids we would call in to see him making the oil near his ‘humpy hut’ and to have a chat when we were out rabbiting, as nobody else talked to him and we knew he was OK. He took the time to show us how he treated the eucalyptus leaves to get the oil, we were polite and listened to his stories, because we were really were interested, it didn’t seem odd to us he lived the way he did. That was how he made a living, it was something he obviously knew a great deal about, and he was his own boss! We walked for miles around the very hilly country out back of Rydal towards Mount Walker, Mount Lambie or Wallerawang setting rabbit traps with Laurie Clements and Peter Gardiner and one or two other mates from the town side of the railway line, I can’t recall their names, some were from properties or camps just outside Rydal. We caught plenty of rabbits when we needed to, setting rabbit traps on Friday afternoon and check them early next morning. We carried small hand picks for digging out burrows and pocket knives for cleaning. We always gutted the rabbits as we got them from the traps, which lightened the load for the trek back home!
A Story to Remember - 201123
7
The Lost Mine Trip David Flynn, Bill Wilson and I took off one early morning intending to follow Solitary Creek to Sodwalls and come back along the railway line. On the way however Bill and David decided to show me how to tickle trout along the creek, which ran alongside the railway line pretty well, towards Sodwalls. We caught a couple of trout which went well for lunch along with buttered bread and some potatoes the ‘big boys’ had brought along. We only got as far as ‘Watercress Gully’, which ran into Solitary Creek and the ‘big boys’ decided we would go gold mine hunting, they were sure there was an old abandoned gold mine nearby in one of the gullies, so the search was on. We walked up a couple of gullies and found one that had a small water course running down the gully into Solitary Creek. We did locate an old mine entrance much further up the gully, probably about three or four hundred yards. By that time we had spent several hours getting there and tickling trout so we stopped for lunch, lit a fire to cook the trout and spuds, which went with the buttered bread sandwiches (pre-prepared by our Mum’s). Then it was into the mine entrance and we made our way along the floor but once it became totally black about 50-60 feet into the level mine shaft, we got a bit concerned as we didn’t carry a torch. We tried making a fire torch out of dead leaves and branches but that didn’t work too good as the torch would go out just as we got to where the floor of the shaft was covered with water. We weren’t smart enough to realise the oxygen supply was probably getting low as we made a bigger torch so it would last and the water was getting a bit deep as we started to move down a slope in the floor of the mine. Either Bill or David pushed it a bit and walked further in until the water was up to their chest, then he dived down a bit but couldn’t touch the bottom, so we thought that might have been a shaft. We couldn’t see in to where he was but he could see us and the ground in between looking out towards the mine entrance, regardless we thought that’s it! So we called him back and agreed it was time to get out of there and head home along the railway line as it was getting late and that was the quickest route. None of us had a watch and we had badly miscalculated the time it would take to get home we still didn’t rush any until it started to get dark! Arriving home in the dark about 8pm that night we were met at the railway gates by several sets of angry parents with real torches . Nobody knew where we were going because we didn’t tell anyone , we were trusted kids , always home on time; except this time . All Mum’s were so glad to see us home safe but it was whack whack with the strap from Dad across the legs for me, all the way home. From that time on, we always told our Mum’s exactly what we had planned for the day.
A Story to Remember - 201123
8
Terry’s Brewery Lorry Hit by Train - Rydal Level Crossing This is yet another story for which I was berated by one of my siblings and that continued for decades as the story generally only came up occasionally, within the family environment. However Fiona and I travelled to Rydal as part of our honeymoon trip where we spoke with locals, including the publican at the Alexandria Hotel Rydal who knew absolutely nothing of the crash, so the research began and it continued on and off for many years until I found solid proof! In local Lithgow newspaper microfilm records at Lithgow Library. Newspaper clippings ???? About 6pm on Thursday 22nd December 1955 (date not memory - obtained from paper archives) while I was mowing the grass in our backyard I heard a loud noise, looked up and saw a train engine immediately after it had collided with a yellow soft drink delivery truck at the railway crossing gates which were about 250-300 yards from Rydal Railway Station. The engine pushed the lorry along the track until the train came to a stop at the station. Despite significant damage to the lorry the cabin remained pretty well intact and the driver just climbed out of the cabin in the middle of the station between the two sets of lines, which was in place at that time. As I know now a passenger must have jumped from the lorry immediately prior to the impact, but he wasn’t located until some time after the collision. The vehicle was travelling out of Rydal towards Wallerawang and had stalled on the crossing as the train, which was ‘special run train’ not listed on the gatekeepers schedule, hence the level crossing gates were open to traffic - 22nd December 1955. Discovered at Lithgow Library on 22nd Feb 2018 - I can’t recall the researchers name but he found the record for me on microfilm! I ran the short distance from home to the station and got there as the train came to a stop right in the middle of the platform, where the driver climbed out from the wreckage, appar - ently unharmed. As he clambered from the wreck the Station Master Greg Featherstone jumped down onto the tracks and said, Mate we should charge you for a yellow ticket from the railway gates to the station ”. The driver of the lorry was Johnny Zorz, former Australian boxing champion and a very popular Lithgow sporting personality, which made this event all very strange, as all the locals I talked with initially, six or eight maybe, many of whom had lived in Rydal all their lives, had absolutely no knowledge of the accident! Speaking with many current and older Rydal residents over recent years, since 1983 to be precise, when Fiona and I visited Rydal while on our short honeymoon. I have spoken with six or seven locals over time, including Greg Featherstones daughter, and none have any knowledge of the incident and generally dismiss any such suggestion. So I was determined to continue my research to find some record of the incident, I did and was able to confirm the occurrence at Lithgow Library on 22nd February 2018 within micro film records - I was assisted by library researcher Bruce ???? at the ‘new library’ in Main Street near where Woolies used to be. Around the time we moved to Rydal Joan had a serious brush with death while being
A Story to Remember - 201123
9
transported by Ambulance from Lithgow Hospital to Sydney (Lidcombe Hospital probably) for specialist treatment after being diagnosed with Osteomyelitis We followed the ambu- lance in Dad’s old 1936 Ford Sedan with Mum, Lynnie and me, we tended to look after our own in those days. No dropping the kids off at the neighbours, which was more unlikely because of the sudden onset and the lesser known nature of Joan’s illness at that time. Just after we passed through Katoomba the ambulance stopped to attend an issue with Joan, as it so happened doctors later informed Mum and Dad that stop probably saved Joan’s life. For whatever reason, the alertness of the ambulance crew by stopping the ambulance to physically intervene must have created life saving body movement. That could have been anything but my 2023 research on Osteomyelitis confirmed how little we as a family knew of the disease at that time. I don’t know what we did that evening in Sydney, visiting hours cease and we had to leave. I don’t have big sister Karlie anymore with her brilliant memory to help out with this one, however I presume we would have stayed overnight with Mum’s brother Uncle Arthur and Aunt Lillian at Auburn which was just a stone’s throw away from Lidcombe. Joan as I remember had quite a bit of illness during our early days at Rydal and looking at the old b&w photo’s dosen’t help either as the outside of the house looked very ordinary and was ‘very crappy’. Inside the house was OK though as Dad had painted inside where required and layed new ‘lino’ in the bedrooms and kitchen. More timely skills for me to learn as I became Dad’s primary assistant, later in Lithgow when there was just Mum and I, laying lino was a snack! As a side issue to show how much times have changed, out of the blue I came down with measles at Rydal and Mum’s immediate treatment method came into play. This is how it worked, I was covered with a severe rash so on went the pink (Calamine Lotion) ointment over the severe rash. I was placed on the couch in the living room and Mum covered the windows with whatever she could so I was in almost total darkness so I wouldn’t go blind! When I had to go to the loo Mum would bring in the pan as I was not allowed out of that room for three weeks. The exception being when I had to have a bath at night and Mum would place a big brown paper bag over my head, but that only happened once. From then on Mum would bring in the ‘big tub’ which was a portable galvanised iron tub used for washing clothes. Mum would let the smallest amount of light in and she would bathe me carefully moving around the pink ointment. We know somewhat different now, but that was Mum’s general knowledge at the time, and it worked, I didn’t go blind and I was fixed in three weeks.

Bus Travel to School in Lithgow

Going to Lithgow High School in 1956 meant daily travel on the school bus via Hampton, Lowther and McKanes Bridge in an old flat nosed Dennis or Leyland bus operated by Eric
A Story to Remember - 201123
10
Newham’s Bus Service from Lithgow, and we picked up about 10 or 12 other kids along the way. There was room for two people to sit up front with the driver on the nearside, over front wheel with the covered engine bay between the seat and the driver. Because I was first on the bus every day, that seat was mine; it was also much warmer during winter months. Karlene refused to travel on the bus to school and so she boarded at Oakey Park in Lithgow very short time because Karlie was in her final year. Unfortunately Joan missed a lot of school due to ill health and I cannot offer more detail. The bus left Rydal around 7am every day and I used to enjoy talking with the drivers on the way to school, that is how I learned to commu- nicate with other people so well. One day the front nearside suspension collapsed as we ap- proached a sharp bend at the top of a hill near the turn off to McKanes Bridge, the bus ran off the road down an embankment and crashed into a fence. Nobody was hurt except me when I was thrown against the windscreen, no seat belts in those days. Just a big bump on the forehead and a big bear hug from the driver fixed that, he was very relieved, and I was good to go, we were very lucky that day! Photo of similar bus: sometimes I travelled to school with David Flynn’s dad or Billy Wilson’s dad Bob, who was Rydal’s postmaster, they drove us to school whenever there were problems with the bus or driver. We travelled via the Great Western Highway through the pine forest on the concrete road, bypass Wallerawang and direct to Lithgow High School. Coming home was always ineresting as Mr Flynn had a big old Wolsley Sedan and when we got to the top of Tunnel Hill, he would turn the motor off and coast down around all the bends to save petrol, probably for a mile and a half. That might seem a bit strange now but the Wolsley was a big car, and in those days it was a significant petrol saver. As a family we often went out on picnics down to Cox’s River or a few good spot’s along Solitary Creek around Sodwalls and we would pick wild blackberries to sell, Dad would bring five or six purpose made four gallon stainless steel drums. The whole family used to get stuck in and we would fill them with fresh blackberries, Lynnie and I worked hardest really, getting into bushes and we would get Mum and Karlie to reach for the higher bunches. Dad sold them through someone in Wallerawang, I’m not sure how much a full drum was worth, but it was great fun with a picnic lunch we were all very happy and every quid helped in those days.
A Story to Remember - 201123
11
When the annual public school fete was approaching I always volunteered to collect comics, for re-sale, I walked all over Rydal for weeks collecting and of course I had to read ‘all’ the comics first to make sure there were no pages missing! Bonfire Night at Rydal About five or six of us used to gather local dead wood for weeks leading up to ‘bonfire night and we always built the fire up on top of the hill behind Laurie Clements home, his mum made sure we had it quite a way from the house. These fires would be about fifteen feet long, seven or eight feet wide and six foot high, unless one of the competing young blokes could toss a log over six feet. Always a great event and just about all the families would come along and bring a picnic basket and cold drinks, no beer or alcohol of any kind, this was always a ‘family night’. I can’t recall anybody ever organising a bucket of water as we were all on tank water in those days, just in case, but everybody had a lot of fun which lasted until the ‘bonfire’ was out. We would rake all the hot coals up in a heap and toss a bit of dirt over the heap to make sure it was out. This was a family night and people brought along any drinks they might need, but that was it, no alcohol in any form. The working lads and fathers would go down to the Alexander Hotel for a couple of beers after the bonfire as the pub was allowed to stay open just a bit longer on cracker night. We had a couple of large bushfires during our seven or eight years at Rydal but generally the problem areas were around homes built on the fringe of the village, like the Kings place on top of the hill where the Coach Road went on it’s way to Mount Lambie. All of the village would be at the seat of the fire using whatever was at hand to beat the fire out, we didn’t have the bush fire brigade as we do now but there were the old ‘back packs’ made using copper and metal, hold four or five gallons of water and a short hand held hose, not much but enough to do the small bits in those days. Being boys we all wanted to help but we were kept away from the main seat of the fire wall initially, but that soon changed we got the job of filling the back packs for the fire fighters from the village and it was hard yakka. Looking back it seems more likely these fires were just bashed out with tree brances and brute force by the men and a few mothers who joined in. The town spirit was always there, everybody stuck together and helped each other out in time of need, that was a great time to live. Time to Move to Lithgow After I started High School I had to travel to Lithgow on the school bus every day, the bus left Rydal about 7am and got us to school a bit after 8am. The return journey left Lithgow around 3:45pm and dropped us off at Rydal around 5pm, it was always took a bit more time
A Story to Remember - 201123
12
on the way home. Naturally I got involved school sport and in turn weekend sport at Lithgow, playing soccer with the Police Boys Club, tennis and cricket were also on the agenda for the summer. I also started playing hockey with Hotshots, but that didn’t work out because of the extra running me around for Dad, I discussed this with him and he wanted me to try any sport at all, didn’t matter to him as long as I was involved in any sport he would watch my games. So I talked with Mum and we decided to give hockey away for now! Dad would drive me in to Lithgow every Saturday for soccer in the morning and wait for hockey in the afternoon. It was too much for Dad really to have to wait all day, so I could do both sports, particularly when I had an early soccer game and late hockey match, we only did that once! I was the one to bring up how difficult it was for me because ‘I had nothing to do between games’, poor little lad had to fill in one or two hours. Dad and I discussed the dilemma again and it was then I realised just how difficult it was for Dad, he gave up entire day for me! So hockey got the flick! Because Mum and Dad wanted me to get involved in as much sport as I could, they weren’t happy about me tossing hockey away. So they quietly applied for a housing commission house when Dad was offered a bit of a leg up through his contacts at the ‘new’ Wang Power Station, where he worked. Whatever it was it worked out very quickly when the offer of a housing commission home in Lithgow came up. Mum was overjoyed and within a few short weeks we moved to 11 Stewart Street, Lithgow, where I lived for eleven years with Mum, Joan and Lynnie, not so long with Dad as his situation took him to Melbourne. Mum was delighted because we had showers, with running water and hot water heaters, I was over the moon and no more chopping up six ton loads of wood. We still had wood and coal heating in the lounge room, but chopping up that amount of wood took no time at all, Mum had an electric stove. Karlene had already started working at Glenfield Special School, down near Liverpool. Joan tried a couple of jobs including some time at Glenfield with Karlie, but ended up working as a telephonist at Lithgow Telephone Exchange, which she really liked and she seemed to get better health by that time, while Lynette and I continued with our schooling. ‘Lynnie’ and I were real mate’s and we had each other’s back, she would know any girls I showed interest in and she would steer me in the right direction if I strayed a bit too far to the left, or right! I didn’t have to worry about her so much she wasn’t really a social get about at all and just hung out with a few special friends. After I left school I became a sports and pub lad, Lynnie wasn’t the pub type and hung out at the other end of town. So I didn’t really have her back, although she managed to pick one or two boys as friends who always played with opposing teams, they were OK, just played for the wrong team.
A Story to Remember - 201123
13

Wedding’s - Karlene and John 1961

Karlene married John Stockton in 1961 somewhere around Liverpool and that was the last time I ever saw my father who had travelled up from Melbourne to give Karlie away. Karlie and John produced Neil, Cathy and Ian and their lifestyles changed a few years down the track when the Stockton family moved up north near Grafton. The coast is one of my pet dislikes and it seemed like losing contact was a distinct possibility. No way that was going to happen, if it wasn’t a letter or telephone call it was me dropping in for an unannounced visit, on my frequent travels around NSW country areas which was part of my job. Dad is in the far right of this picture. Karlie had a brilliant memory, it was very rare when she could not recall deep details about, people, places or things that have entered our lives at one time or another. She was always my fallback, over the years before we moved north to be nearer, we called each other on a weekly basis, and should I miss a call I got a terse ‘Hello’ when I caught up; fifteen seconds later it was back to normal with a ‘When are you pair coming over again?” My elder sister Joan worked a couple of jobs but ended up, very happily I might add, working at Lithgow Telephone Exchange as a telephonist which she adapted to until she met her future husband, one Patrick Meredith, from Orange and he played rugby league for Orange Cyms. Pat was a one in a million bloke, great family man and father, unfortu- nately when I dropped in for a visit it usually meant a quick stop at his local waterring hole, and that’s when the trouble started!

Joan and Pat 1964

Joan and Pat married in 1964 at Orange, to be sure I was always in trouble with my dear sister from that day on, because I led my new brother and best mate Pat astray every time I came to visit! Well the trouble was worth it, and we loved the challenge of just a couple of beers and I was always assured of a very early breakfast the following day, because that is when I went back home. But it didn’t end there because Joanne and Wayne were to arrive over the years, then more trouble because with Jo it was love at first sight! Joan really enjoyed that aspect and then Bernie Schmich came into the picture and that made things interesting as I saw much
A Story to Remember - 201123
14
less of Jo for a while. Bernie and Jo generated Nick, 'whatsername' (Renae), and Jacko into the family group and love at first sight struck once more with Renae; her beautiful nature was absolutely captivat- ing. From that moment on, life for me has been a captivating journey because I have so much to look forward to with our next chat. 'Whatsername' playfully teases me occasionally, always with a gentle touch.

Allana and Paul 1966

I first met Allana Barrett on the evening of my 21st birthday party at home, as usual Mum had invited relatives from Sydney and Portland, who also hung on for a game of cards after Lynnie and I left for the evening. Diane Jenkins and a couple of friends ar- rived to collect Lynnie and I dropped them off at the Classic Cafe where they usually met up. Allana was among the group there and we were introduced, we met again the following night at The Wreck basketball sta- diun where the weekly dance was held, we had a couple of dances and so our story began. Mum wanted me to get a better job and so I successfully applied for the police in July 1965, later that year Allana and I began dating and we were married the following year in February 1966. I joined the NSW Police Force in August and we added to the collection with Sue- Ellen (Lithgow) born on the same day as I started working as a cop at Newtown Police Station. Our other two girls turned up while we were at Goulburn, Sara-Jayne and Rechelle (Goulburn). Lynn and Alby Married in 1970 Lynnie and Alby Cooper married in 1970, and they produced best mates Damo and Ty with Kellly hanging in the background. I now realise that I have no photo of their wedding, I wasn’t there because Sara-Jayne was only eight weeks old and travel for us was an issue at that time. We were living at Goulburn on Lynnie’s and Alby’s wedding day and a 300km trip for us wasn’t possible. I have a colour photo of Lynnie with Karlie and Joan at 11 Stewart Street but I don’t know where the photo came from. I got the family bit over with here so I can concentrate on what I did, a year or so after we moved to Lithgow Dad’s employment contract with Arcos at Wallerawang came to a close
A Story to Remember - 201123
15
around 1958 and he took up a good opportunity as head chef at a hotel in Melbourne, where he worked for many years and became a serious fan of Essendon in the AFL. As kids know stuff we knew he wouldn’t be coming back home again, so we all got on with life and supported our hard working Mum. At thirteen years of age I began to think more seriously about Mum’s position, so I got a part-time job after school working as a bowser boy at Eric Newhams Ampol garage out on the highway at Bowenfels. Eric’s son Barry Newham ran the servo and once I started working with Barry we got on like a house on fire, add Stan Williams to the mix as he was sort of number three at Newham’s and we bonded very well. I worked very hard at the Ampol once I got used to the job at hand, at my busiest I would work three afternoons a week, after school from 4pm to 8:30pm, then either one or both days at the weekend. The money I brought in was needed, but, I had to convince Mum I should help out finan- cially, by paying board of one pound ten shillings per week. Mum and I were best mates as this time because she would talk to me, she wanted me to finish High School and this way we could make ends meet, so she finally agreed. I worked lots more weekend’s from that day forward, with time off for hockey and cricket. The careers advisor at Lithgow High recommended I should go to St Kilda, Melbourne as trainee telephone technician with the PMG (Post Master General - now Telstra), because my school marks indicated I was suited for trades. Mum wanted me to go because it was a trade and she still had Joan and Lynnie with her. She was very keen because once I had completed my first twelve months training I could transfer back to NSW, so I gave it a go, but three months of living in a large old boarding house in Chapel Street, East St Kilda with three other young blokes, doing the same course as me changed my outlook. They were great mates and we had lots of fun times, we all sang in the Myer Music Bowl but, I had had enough, I was homesick and I missed Mum a great deal, so I came back home to Lithgow! Work was scarce at around Lithgow but I immediately started part-time work again at Newham’s and within four weeks I landed a great fulltime job with Radio Electrix which was an electrical store selling household electrical goods, in Main Street, Lithgow (1960). The business was owned by Ray Cooper and Don Ellery was his radio technician, refrigeration specialist and general service guy. They sold and repaired all sorts of household appli- ances and vacuum cleaners, electric toasters, Sunbeam frying pans and TV’s. TV aerial installations seemed a bit of a challenge at twenty, thirty and forty feet high off the roof, so it seemed like a very interesting job overall, and it was. I was to learn many skills from Don who trained me in washing machine, refrigeration and all types of electrical appliance repairs and how to do service calls. I was very well looked after by the boss because I was a willing worker, and I attended many training workshops at the Electrolux factory in Orange, and Phillips and Westinghouse in Sydney for various appliances, this was a very interesting and important start to my working life. When I did the Phillips electric shaver repair course in Sydney they gave me a new Twin Head shaver, with my initials PRH scrolled into the body. Fifty seven years later I bought my first electric shaver a Remington at Charters Towers, for convenience when travelling, I
A Story to Remember - 201123
16
am now on my second shaver, the only difference is three heads (laughter) but the technology is basically unchanged. The main TV, radio and small appliance workshop was beneath Radio Electrix shop in Main Street and connected directly with next door’s Economy Shoe store owned by Ray Coopers brother Ken, who lived in Sydney. Their main salesman was ‘Darby Cook’, a single bloke known for his love of beer and his ability to consume copious amounts without gaining weight, was a regular visitor to our workshop. He would often drop by for a chat and eventually introduced me to the Lansdowne Hotel in Lithgow. This sports minded establishment became his go-to spot for lunch, where he would order a salad sandwich and a middy. It didn’t take long for the boss, Ray, and Don to join Darby in his Friday afternoon pub visits after work. And soon enough, I found myself drawn to the lively atmosphere and ca- maraderie at the Lansdowne Hotel as well. Little did I know at the time that this pub was not only a popular hangout for our group but also the home of the Hornets Hockey and Cricket Club. In a heartbeat, I became an active member of this tight-knit community, forging lasting friendships that would endure a lifetime. The Lansdowne Hotel quickly became more than just a place for a casual lunch or a post- work drink. It became a hub of social activity and a gathering spot for like-minded individuals who shared a passion for both hockey and good company. The walls of the pub echoed with laughter, stories, and the clinking of glasses as we celebrated victories, commiserated losses, and bonded over our shared experiences. Darby, with his larger-than-life personality and love for a good time, was the catalyst that brought us all together. His infectious enthusiasm and warmth created an environment where everyone felt welcome and included. And for that, we will be forever grateful to him. So, here’s to Darby Cook, the man who introduced us to the Lansdowne Hotel and forever changed our lives. Cheers to the memories we made and the friendships that continue to thrive, all thanks to a single bloke who loved a beer. In 1961, I obtained my driver’s license, allowing me to independently handle service calls. This was an incredible opportunity as it gave me the chance to meet new people and assist them while Don focused on the more technical aspects of our work at the workshop. We had a spacious workshop located in Rifle Parade, right behind Ray Cooper’s home on Martini Parade. However, this workshop was rarely used except for storing trade-in appliances such as refrigerators and washing machines. Recognizing the potential of this unused space, I proposed to Don that we could repair the non-functioning trade-in appliances and sell them. Afterwards, we could salvage any valuable spare parts and properly dispose of the remaining unusable parts. This sugges- tion was put into action and turned out to be a success. In fact, our boss was so impressed with the results that he rewarded Don with a well-deserved pay raise.
A Story to Remember - 201123
17
Overall, this initiative not only generated additional revenue for the company but also allowed us to reduce waste by utilizing good spare parts from the trade-in appliances. It was a win-win situation for everyone involved. During my time at the company, which lasted approximately two years, I had taken on a significant workload. In my final year, I was responsible for service calls and working alone in the shed on Rifle Pde. Due to my proven track record as a hardworking and reliable employee, I was trusted to work unsupervised. At this point, Don, a colleague, suggested that I ask for a pay raise, especially considering the increased workload. Don had recently received a pay increase himself. Currently, I was earning £4/7/6d per week, equivalent to $8.75. I approached Ray Cooper and asked for a pay increase, he offered a rise to £5 flat, or $10.00. Although it may not seem like a substantial increase, I considered it a small victory and reluctantly accepted the pay rise. However, it became apparent that Don was not particularly impressed with the outcome of “my pay rise.” One afternoon, we had a serious discussion about it at the pub with another coworker, ‘Darby’ Cook. Both Don and Darby agreed that I deserved a higher increase. Despite their opinions, we ultimately decided to leave the matter as it was. I was content with my work and enjoyed spending time at the Lansdowne pub. A few weeks later while erecting a thirty foot TV aerial on the roof of the store, three stories high and directly beside the railway line at Lithgow Railway Station, I had a very scary fall from an extension ladder and my feet went straight through a section of fibro roofing directly above Ray Cooper’s desk, he looked up and said ‘Nice of you to drop in’. Con- cerned both he and Don came up to survey the damage, they were both very happy I was OK. Overall the pay raise really was an insult so I started thinking about moving on and giving some other vocation a bit of a go, I was losing interest and working hard for peanuts, I left some time later after breaking my leg playing rugby league, it was perfect timing because the boss complained when I turned up for work in plaster, so I quit, on the spot and hobbled back out the front door. I had linked up with Hornets Hockey who were based at the Lansdowne Hotel, they were the top hockey club in Lithgow at that time and I played ‘B’ Grade, we were premiers in 1963-64, travelled all over NSW to hockey tournaments and life was good. I had found friendship with dozens and dozens of hockey, cricket and rugby league players that were everlasting, it all seems so long ago, great memories. Wombats rugby league was formed from within Hornets hockey club and my first game was against Wallerawang in the rain, ‘Bluey’ Rushworth and ‘Wally’ Gaynor gave me words of advice on the way out, watch him, if ‘Colin Steele’ moves anywhere, just tackle him, so I did. On the way back home, we either won 13-12 or lost 12-13, but Bluey and Wally reckoned I played well above expectations, they were really pleased. Mistakenly I thought if I was that good why bother going to training, I didn’t, and Bluey has been mad at me ever
A Story to Remember - 201123
18
since, he never let me forget, we all miss him and I’ll never forget him! I should have listened but I never played any sport where I was fully fit, I reluctantly went to training for physical sports and very late in life I am finding out why! Somewhere in all this I managed to break my right leg (femur) in the Business Houses Rugby League competition at Lithgow showground, number two ground, and they reckon you could hear the snap in the grandstand, I spent a few days in hospital but I cannot recall anything about how I got on at work, which year it was, or who we were playing against. I could spend time researching to find out, but when is not important! A few weeks later Mum was working in the spinning room at Lithgow Woollen Mills, Bob Morrow was the manager and he asked her how I was going. While chatting he told Mum he had heard lots of good things about my work ethic on the grapevine and he wondered if I might be interested in a full time driving job at the mill. Would I ever; Mum was pleased and so I went to a meeting at the Woollen Mills the following Saturday (this took a special Friday trip) Mr Rosen, from Mascot Head Office, Bob Morrow and I talked for quite a while, they took me into the mill where Mum worked and told me what I would be doing. Mr Rosen said “I’ll pay you ten quid a week if you want the job”. I accepted his offer, Mr Rosen was Jewish and I learned lots from this man during the next three years. We shook hands and the deal was done, then he told me after we shook hands, that he arrived at the mill on Friday so he could ‘meet me’. Although Jewish people do not work on Saturday he said this was meeting a new friend, not work! After three months and count- less return trips to Mascot I passed my ‘special’ ‘C’ class truck licence so he gave me a raise in pay, put me on ‘his staff group’ and paid me eighteen quid a week, or $36.00 which was fantastic at that time because the majority of my mates were getting less than $10.00. So I got to be very good friends with everyone at Mascot, and Mario the hard working Italian, was the head man at the Mascot factory and his first words to me were “The boss reckons you are a good worker, we’ll see about that, in the warehouse you work for me!”. Indeed he did and he had me doing up to three trips a day from Lithgow to Sydney, in a VW Kombi loaded with blankets or eight bales of wool on the trip home. One day after we had off loaded the rolls of blankets Mario took off to see the boss and there was nobody in the warehouse to help me load the eight bales of wool, so I did it myself. Mario was astounded when he returned, as I was tying the load down, he conceded I wasn’t too bad a worker after all! Mario told the boss who decided to buy a new three ton Commer flattop so we could carry more blanket rolls. I knew I could get a special “‘C” class licence, so I applied with the licencing sergeant one morning, he took me for a driving test and the job was done, in just a couple of hours. Mr Rosen knew the licencing sergeant, who didn’t do driving tests, but he occasionally drove new Holden cars from Sydney back to the local Holden Dealer at Hassans Walls Motors. It’s a small world as I was personal friends with the sales man- ager, Neville Kerrison or ‘Kero’ as we called him.
A Story to Remember - 201123
19
So it wasn’t long before I had an occasional passenger who I would drop off along Parra- matta Road at Homebush, on my way out to Mascot. At that time I owned a Standard Super 10 Sedan and twelve months down the track I happened to run into the rear end of another vehicle one Friday night, right in front of the Classic Cafe, which was one of the main meeting places for Lithgow’s youth back in the 1960’s. As luck would have it the licencing sergeant, who knew me personally was on duty, so he attended the accident and took particulars as there was not a lot of damage, except to my front end. That was the last I heard of that, and so Mr Rosen was right as it’s always helpful to have ‘good friends’. Mario lived around Petersham and one day he took me to his home to meet his family, including grandparents, with lots of Italian fanfare, his wife sat me down and the whole family listened to my story. We ate a real Italian meal, it was a feast and these were valuable lessons in dealing with other people and cultures, I didn’t want to leave that day but Mario kicked me out after lunch, as they had to clean up. What I learnt that day would stay with me for the rest of my life, respect! I know there are times when I get a bit excited and outgoing I can spin a good yarn, but really I am a quiet, respectful individual, just like Mario’s family. I was a member of the Police Boys Club, played soccer with them, it was in the 60’s and I got involved in boxing with Colin Holden and Constable 1/C Ted Doherty. It wasn’t long before my good mate Ted started pushing for me to join ‘the cops’. He took me to the Police Station to meet the other cops and I arranged to take one of the Sergeants down to Sydney with me in the truck, because he used to occasionally drive ‘new’ Holden cars back to Lithgow and he got $20.00 per trip, everyone was doing it tough in those days! Mr Rosen loved this, “It’s not always what you know, but who you know, always remember that”. That’s life and any time you have an opportunity to do someone a good turn, just do it, one never knows what’s around the corner. The Woollen Mill fell on hard times and they were laying workers off, but not the highly skilled workers like Mum because they were experienced across multiple skill sets like looms, spinning, weaving and whatever. Mr Rosen called me in and he wanted me to work from Mascot, but I couldn’t leave Mum, so I agreed to leave as they were keeping Mum on until everything shut down which could take another year or so. By this time I was twenty with plenty of life experience, or so I thought at the time, as I was to find out this was just the beginning, with lot’s more learning to do! I wasn’t out of work for long and within a week I had a new job working on the NSW railway in a gang of fettler’s laying the new 220 foot long rails for the Indian Pacific, along the western railway line between Tarana and Brewongle. Unlike today these rails had to be manhandled into place, from the side of the existing railway lines, wooden sleepers cut from Ironbark, Tallowood and Rivergum were all replaced manually. One Eric Wakefield was our ganger, he was in his late fifties, had been fettling all his life and that was all he knew, he could only sign his name, that was all and he was a tough as teak. So away I went learning how to remove old sleepers using a pigsfoot and sledge hammer to do the job. This was real hard work, but I really enjoyed working in the outdoors, and our ganger kept us on the go from kick off to knock off time. Eric actually comes back into my story
A Story to Remember - 201123
20
many years later at Menindee, where he was leading a railway gang on the same project out near Menindee. I worked with another old mate from Lithgow, Kerry Weekes, who was a pretty good rugby league player who could run like the wind and as a hockey winger with Hornets so could I, so this led to some strange activities for this gang of fettlers. Laying new railway lines meant replacing the wooden sleepers, they had to be manhandled onto a flatbed trolley, dropped off to a couple of workers to do the replacement. Repeat the process over and over, but Eric was very pleased when Kerry and I started tossing these sleepers on our shoulder and compete with each other to move them around much quicker, the other blokes didn’t mind because it was saving them work. When it rained all work stopped and we all sat in the back of the truck for hours playing cards to keep ourselves amused until the rain stopped, that didn’t suit Kerry and I, so we would race each other about 100 yards up and down the side of the tracks for something positive to do! The rest of the gang would cheer us on and one or two would bet on who would win, Kerry won mostly, no protests! We got bored with that type of work after seven or eight months, we certainly got much fitter, but we both decided to throw the towel in and get another job. Within a couple of weeks I started work at Marcus Clarkes furniture store selling carpets, just a couple of doors up from Radio Electrix. They did carpet laying as well and Peter Davies was my workmate and teacher, Peter sent me a very nice poetic letter for our wedding in February 1966. I met Allana Barrett in the winter of 1965 at the Classic Cafe when I dropped Lynnie off one Friday or Saturday evening. During my brief conversation with Allana I discovered she worked at Fossey’s and lived with her parents up Pottery Estate and one of Lynnies mates suggested we all meet up at the Wreck as Col Joye or some other band was playing the next week, and so it was meant to be I guess. Three or four weeks later we became a couple travelling around everywhere on the Blue Mountains, Blackheath swimming pool or local swimming holes down Cox’s River. We also went down the Wolgan Valley where Allana’s parents owned a property where they kept their horses for Allana. We married the following year after I had been leant upon by my good mate Constable 1/C Ted Doherty and a few other local cops to join the NSW Police Force. Allana wasn’t happy about me taking off to Sydney, I tried to reassure her that all would be OK and I would be home every weekend, but she wanted to go to Sydney with me and there was no possibil- ity of living together in those days. It was a difficult position as all I thought about was joining the cops, Allana had other ideas, so without upsetting the applecart, she resolved the dilemma. Having a steady job was very important in those days, so being accepted as a police recruit made Allana’s parents very happy, not mention the local cops, and when I asked for permission to marry they said OK, with no conditions attached, it was all go.
A Story to Remember - 201123
21
About fifty or so family and friends attended our wedding, my best mate ‘Darcy’ Evans was best man and so Allana and I were married at St Pauls C of E Lithgow on 19th February 1966. The reception was held at, naturally, Lithgow Police Boys Club which we got for free after which Allana and I drove off into the sunset in my Standard Super 10 sedan, with the traditional ribbons and empty cans rattling along behind the car. Although we were supposed to be heading to Blackheath for our first night of married life, it didn’t work out that way as Allana took sick and we spent our first night with ‘the rels Sandra and David May in Lithgow. Lithgow, Green Valley, Dulwich Hill, Marrickville, Goulburn, Broken Hill & Charlestown. A twelve year family history from our beginning and the road to Newcastle, along with everyday issues we had to deal with during those times. After we married in 1966 Allana and I lived in a sparsley furnished semi detached Terrace House in Lithgow St, Lithgow, knowing we would be moving to Sydney later in the year. I was working at Marcus Clarks furniture store and Allana continued working at Fosseys, pending my call up to the NSW Police Force which was in August 1966. While I did my initial six week training in Sydney Allana stayed with best friend’s Joan and Les Drury in Lithgow because we were getting close to the birth of our first child. After my six week training course my first station was Newtown, and, on my very first day on the job Sue-Ellen was born. I was notified as our group of about seven were being introduced to our senior sergeants at Newtown Police Station, everything stopped and they arranged three days off for me, immediately; so I could go back to Lithgow and meet Sue-Ellen, our new family addition. The roster sergeant added; By the way Horton when you return you will go straight onto night shift! ” Loud cheers from my workmates. By the time I got back to Lithgow Joan and Les Dury had the move organised for us, everything was packed and ready to go! Allana was spending lots of time getting to know Sue-Ellen, a few more phone calls and we started the move to Sydney. We moved fast, packed our goods in the Standard Super 10 said our goodbye’s to family and headed to Green Valley where we stayed with my sister Karlene for a couple of weeks, until we found suitable housing around Dulwich Hill, which was much nearer to Newtown. Our first unit was in a block of flats in Osgood Ave, but it only lasted a few weeks, as Allana was uncomfortable, we were one among 60 other units with over 250 people in the building. Allana wasn’t used to living that way back home, so our agent found us a two bedroom semi-detached weatherboard house just a few streets away which suited Allana. She fitted in immediately with our neighbours who also had a baby, son (‘ Michael’), everyone got along fine.
A Story to Remember - 201123
22
In those days night shift lasted three weeks so for Allana being alone at night in Sydney, after we left Karlies , was very difficult, it was hard to deal with but she tolerated it. We didn’t like city living at all, so we had to find a solution, and we finally did, however in the meantime these are a few selected bits & pieces of how we faced our daily life in those days. There was a small shopping centre at Dulwich Hill which was only a few blocks away, so Allana was able to get out for a little while to shop for the essentials, then it was back to the flat . After the first week it was very obvious that this was not our lifestyle at all and it was Allana who spoke with the Real Estate agent when he called to see how we were settling in, he was a really good agent and he found us a two bedroom flat in a semi- detached house in Dulwich Hill, this was more like home, Allana was comfortable and she got on well with our joint neighbours! Working night shift was an eye opener, we worked with an experienced officer for the first week, either a Sergeant or Senior Constable, then we were on our own. There were four major b eats, King Street, Enmore Road, St Peters and Erskineville Road, we walked each beat alone, with a torch and no direct contact with station. The occasional drive past of the PD Van containing the senior beat officer and his driver ( one of us new constables ) would keep a check on us, from time to time. When the PD got tied up that became a bit difficult and we could use the public phones, late night cafe’s or local pubs, they were always helpful. Our first exciting incident surrounded a stolen car incident from St Peters where the PD spotted a stolen car and gave chase, the offender got caught up among the back lanes so he pulled up and took off. As it so happened one of my class mates Constable Ralph Ezzy was on that beat and right on the spot, by chance, and he saw the offender hop a fence into a back yard and they found him hiding in a shed and Ralph made the arrest. When I think back I wonder how we did our job in those early days, but we have been fortunate to see the introduction of modern technology over many years, to give us a helping hand. I didn’t see it then, but I do now, how I valued my life experience at that time, how I was brought up by my parents, and my teachers at school. Visits to RPA hospital as a result of motor vehicle accidents were regular and my first fatal accident was in City Road near the University, two vehicles collided violently and a young sportsman had his leg torn off in the collision. I had to attend the post mortem examina- tion, along with four other probationers and one got crook and had to walk out, for us it was our first real front line experience. Two of us also delivered our first death message to his parents, that was something else! In King Street just past Newtown Railway Station former Australian middleweight boxing champion Clive Stewart had slot car track and he always liked a chat with the beat cops at night, moreso because he liked a bit of company which was pretty well known and that helped discourage any troublemakers. Not all the cops stopped for a chat, but those that did always came away with a bit more local knowledge which came in handy when trying to solve petty crime in the area. I always wanted to be a motorcycle cop and there was a position coming up over the next
A Story to Remember - 201123
23
couple of months at Newtown and it had the added advantage of no nightshift , so I completed the motor cycle training course at St Ives and transferred to the traffic branch at Newtown, no more night shifts and that made Allana very very happy. We had a good crew Harry Stubbs, Basil Menogue, Ray McDermott, Brian ‘Chicka’ Moore, Sgt Ray Williams was OIC with Henry ??? 2IC. They all called in home at Dulwich Hill to meet Allana very early on, to reassure her they were as near as the telephone while I was working. I attended a serious accident on the Princes Highway at St Peters where the driver was badly pinned behind wheel in VW Kombi and it looked pretty bad so a bystander, passing fire crew and a tow truck driver got the guy out before the Ambulance arrived at the scene. As a result of that extraction the driver became a paraplegic, that was an extremely important part of learning to be a cop, making on the spot life and death decisions every other day. That day I learnt the importance of building relationship with Ambo, Firies, doctors, tow trucks, rescue squads, security people, casualty staff and body snatchers, watch, listen and learn. Everything Stood Still All was good until about 10 months later when I had a serious motorcycle accident, en route to another serious motor vehicle accident involving a young child. I collided with the rear of a stationary utility just past St Peters Station, Princes Highway and Unwins Bridge Road intersection. I cannot remember anything about the accident but it appear’s the utility was stationary waiting to turn into Unwin’s Bridge Road when my motorcycle collided with the ute. I was knocked unconscious and was taken to RPA Hospital and treated by a Neuro Surgeon, Dr Segelov. This is how the cops looked after me, they contacted Mum personally within thirty minutes of the accident, arrangements were in place for the Highway Patrol to get Mum to RPA, ASAP. With Mum they organised for Joan & Pat to travel from Orange, collect Mum on the way through Sydney and the HWP would escort them all the way to RPA. I was unconscious for three days in intensive care at RPA and the doctors didn’t think I’d survive, but I did. When I got out of hospital my boss arranged a transfer to Goulburn on general duties, after conferring with Allana; who didn’t want me riding motorcycles any - more. My boss Sergeant Ray Williams explained shift work in the country was vastly different to Sydney, I didn’t really want to give up the bikes but Allana was really frightened. Ray Williams was on her side and said ‘This is a no brainer Paul, you are lucky to be here, don’t push your luck”! I can get you a Mini Cooper but your wife won’t be happy, your choice! This was a chance for us to get back to the bush, quick time so it was GD’s. We upgraded our vehicle from a Standard Super 10 to a much larger 1956 Holden Special which I bought for $150 - a new one cost around $1800 at the time. We both wanted out of Sydney so we jumped at the chance of a transfer to Goulburn. We were allowed three days to travel to Goulburn and find somewhere to live, along with eighteen dollars ex - penses ($18.00) and we got right into it, the quicker the better.
Allana & Sue-Ellen at Goulburn swimming pool
A Story to Remember - 201123
24
We found a small flat in the main street, 119 Auburn St, at the rear of Goulburn sad - dler Bill Dutallis, who was a legend in the area, a great bloke and he gave us an open ended rental until we could find a house. The ground floor consisted of a very small bathroom/laundry at the back, an outside toilet and a very narrow back - yard with no grass. The kitchen was very small with very ordinary lighting, about three square metres, with a slow combus - tion stove like Allana was used to using and she loved it, as it was just like her Mum had. The dining room of about four square metres stood between the kitchen and the stairwell adjacent the rear entrance to the Saddlers shop. Upstairs and above the shop were the two bedrooms. Bill Dutallis had never intended to rent the flat until it had been updated and painted, and that was unlikely so I offered to work on the kitchen and laundry with painting and laying tiles in return, and he agreed. We were both happy with the arrangement at that time but as you can see from the only photo I have taken, out in the back yard, it was not very impressive! Bill had access to the external toilet via an exit door at the bottom of the stairwell at the rear of his shop. This was never a problem for Allana as she would often make morning tea for Bill and being a pretty good horsewoman herself she would often watch him hand craft beautiful saddles from the ground up, with Sue-Ellen always nearby in her bassinet. Photo: Sue-Ellen at front of Saddlers in Goulburn 1968 Rentals were very hard to get at Goulburn in 1967 so we didn’t have much choice, in fact we were lucky to score the rental we did within a day, and, the flat did have some basic furniture which was a bonus for us at the time. Over the next few weeks Allana made lots of shopping trips, which was just outside the front door. Photo of our back yard! While checking out the shops she was offered a part time job, which she wanted to take , but I was back on shift work again and we decided it was better for me to get extra work ( Police were not allowed to have 2nd jobs ), if discovered you could be sacked, but cops had to do something because the wages were so low. My take home pay was about $90.00 per fortnight at the time so there was very little money over to save for a deposit on a home. However; I soon found out how to get work without causing any problems at work.
A Story to Remember - 201123
25
We wanted to buy a house, we had no money in the bank and a young child, so we had to work on it and we I did, however working so much in my spare time didn’t allow enough family time; I had no idea of the problems that would arise! We wanted to buy our first home - at Goulburn Over the next twelve months I found plenty of part time work as a builders offsider, in shearing sheds ( Crookwell ), land clearing, carting hay ( Lake George ), fixing small property dams, clearing dead trees for firewood at Ozzie Rabjohns at ( Woodhouselee ), rebuilding washing machines at the rear of Clive Flacks dealership in Auburn St Goulburn (Aust Hockey player) who sold cars, fridges and electrical appliances. This was the best paying job where I was paid fitter and turners rates which was double my police pay and I got excellent discounts when buying our electrical goods such as a first fridge and washing machine, this was work I was trained for. Shiftwork hours at Goulburn were 5am-1:30pm, 1pm-9:30pm and Night Shift 9pm-5:30am, which worked OK for those of us who had second jobs, which was a larger of police because we were all in the same boat. Shifts were arranged as we could work many hours between shifts, and on rest days, that is exactly what I did. This was fantastic for us as we had no furniture or major household appliances such as a mix-master, fridge or washing machine . So it wasn’t just a matter of putting the extra dollars into the bank to buy a house, we were buying whitegoods also, so I did more and more part-time work to make ends meet. My focus was on putting money in the bank and I didn’t see what was coming! I was working so much I just came home to sleep . As things turned out it was me who was causing all the problems, I could operate in so many varied types of work that getting a job wasn’t a problem. Extra jobs had me away from home between shifts, particularly on rest days, so Allana & Sue-Ellen were alone for long periods of time, in particular , during the first fifteen months. Initially the situation must have been very difficult for Allana to deal with but I should have noticed something. I was getting as much extra work as I could, money in the bank was growing and everything seemed fine. This was important to us as we were saving a deposit for our new home, which had become a real possibility with the assis - tance of our new bank manager. There were no sign’s of any personal problems with Allana, she never complained to me, but apparently had done so to our doctor; as I was to find out later! Early on in Goulburn before I started working other jobs we did have time together and we tried our hand at making ginger beer, stacking heaps of full bottles in the laundry to ferment, sometimes we got it right, but after many bottles had blown the tops off we decided to give ginger beer making away. Allana didn’t drive at that time so her day consisted of looking after Sue-Ellen, doing the housework and visiting the shops which were right outside the front door, which really wasn’t our front door as we came and went via the back entrance. We didn’t see daylight
A Story to Remember - 201123
26
from anywhere inside the flat, the lights were on all day and they weren’t very bright either. TV at that time was black and white! Photo: Allan & Sue-Ellen window shopping at Goulburn 1968 Hindsight is a great thing but, shopping with very little money to spend, was the only variation for Allana and life must have been very difficult and boring spending so much time alone with Sue-Ellen . Apparently our new doctor at Goulburn had prescribed some medication for her but back then women didn’t discuss all their conversations with their doctor at home, unless it was very important . Around 1967-8 new housing commission homes built in Goulburn were available to buy, if you qualified ! We qualified and were placed on a housing priority list via our new Bank Loans Manager, who opened a special account for our loan application. Our position in the list depended on how quickly we could get the $990.00 deposit in the account, so I got more work, as my gross salary at that time was only about $90.00 per fortnight. We had to build the bank account up to qualify, and we both agreed it was going to be tough, but we had to cop it on the chin and do it! Back home one day after working one of my second jobs, I found Allana in a very dis - tressed state in the dining room with an empty bottle of pills sitting on the table in front of her. I started to say something but she started shouting at me while pointing at the bottle, then she pushed me away when I went to touch her, I had no idea what was going on, but, it didn’t take long to work out, she had taken an overdose! I didn’t know what the tablets were for, but apparently she had them for a week or two and I wanted to know what they were, and quickly to identify what problem was, but she was hysterical and did not make any sense! So I slapped her across the face to get her to wake up to herself. Why? Because they did that in the movies to get people back to their senses. Stupid I know , but; I was in panic mode, this was my wife and this was 1968. I would react very differently with the benefit of hindsight, however Allana never expected that, and neither did I, but it worked, she just stared at me and stopped yelling. The instant reaction should have told me a lot about the situation, but this was my wife , and, my inexperience left me wanting, I didn’t know what I was confronted with in this situation. The instructions on tablets were ordinary, such as ‘take as directed’ or something similar, but I didn’t know what they were; or what they were for and she wouldn’t tell me! I had never seen her like this as we didn’t argue, I only helped with Sue-Ellen and I didn’t interfere with anything about being a mother or cooking, etc, life was easier that way. We had very few possessions and we were looking forward to buying our first home and here was my wife acting in a way I have never seen before. Fortunately Bill was working late in the shop, he called the Ambulance, then came back to us and talked to Allana and I as we waited. She seemed to settle down a bit, but would not talk to me , just Bill, so I waited out front for the Ambulance and apparently that was when
A Story to Remember - 201123
27
when Allana rang the Police, to report me for hitting her . Why would she do that, she took the overdose and I was only trying to help her? In my work education and experience I had learnt the primary reason people overdose; is to either commit suicide or get attention! Within minutes the ambulance arrived and the crew were attending to Allana, they did the usual checks to evaluate her condition and took her to Goulburn Base Hospital. Bill’s wife arrived to care for Sue-Ellen ( Bill was Sue-Ellens godfather ) while I followed the Ambu - lance to casualty, it was sometime later actually, as Allana didn’t want me around, so I gave her plenty of space. Kenmore Mental Hospital Bill told me about the phone call some time after I had explained to him what had hap - pened when I got home from working one of my second jobs near Crookwell. I also explained the process and what could happen to Allana at the hospital as Bill was Sue- Ellens godfather, so he certainly was in the family loop. Most of these facts would have been discovered at the hospital, but the Police would only have been partly informed as a matter of procedure. However it was possible Allana could end up in Kenmore Mental Hospital for up to several weeks for observation, counselling and treatment, for whatever caused this event. I was anxious to get to the hospital, but I had to wait until they gave me the OK to go up. Talking with Bill and his wife helped and they suggested I give her some time’ which was very appropriate at the time so I talked everything over with them, it was then that Bill told me about the call to the police . I could not under - stand that! I certainly do understand now, in no uncertain terms, from the information and peo - ple I researched, medical contacts and family friends , I have since spoken to. Photo: Kenmore Mental Hospital Main Adminis - trat ion at Goulburn in 1968 . That phone call had placed my job at risk and I was facing the sack , full stop! Details of the call were recorded on the Telephone Pad ( a permanent detailed written record of all phone calls received ) at the police station. The record could be used as evidence during any formal proceedings against me, so I made sure all details were included, I was concerned about my wife and child, not me, I didn’t do anything wrong, albeit not the way to go. I had no intent to hurt Allana , I just didn’t know any better, at that time so, there shouldn’t be any problem. As I was to discover, that’s not the way it works! Kenmore Asylum, also known as Kenmore Hospital or Kenmore Psychiatric Hospital is now a heritage-listed decommissioned psychiatric hospital located in Goulburn, but in 1968 it was in full operation and capable of housing over 700 patients.
A Story to Remember - 201123
28
In 1968 attempting to commit suicide was considered a crime, the law was overdue for change, but it was the law . One of our regular Police tasks was escorting people to Kenmore from across the state, a large number of those had overdosed or attempted to take their own life in some manner. I knew the essentials of the Mental Health Act, all local police did, as we dealt with it regularly, but when it became personal, it was very difficult to deal with, to say the least. Historically epileptics, women with post-natal depression and teenagers with learning difficulties were considered of ''unsound mind'' and many were declared insane under the Lunacy Act. That was the way it was in those days and this was my wife, the mother of our child and I certainly didn’t want her in Kenmore, for any reason or time, I had to keep her out of that institution! I knew from previous experience at the hospital that admission was mostly a forgone conclusion , so off to Kenmore for seven to fourteen days for assessment, and possibly longer. After I had explained everything to the doctor in charge at Goulburn Base Hospital they kept her under observation for a few extra hours. The doctor explained he could not give me any details prior to the upcoming sessions at Kenmore, which I already knew, so they finally allowed her to return home with me provided she had adult company while I was at work. That I understand now, but I didn’t get the big picture at the time, but I trusted the doctor’s decision. There was no concern for the welfare of Sue-Ellen, I was very happy Allana wasn’t going direct to Kenmore , and at the time I didn’t realise exactly what the doctor’s had done for us both. Medical staff at the hospital suggested we should attend a full counselling session at Kenmore for assessment, in lieu of admission, because there was a toddler involved. Whatever Allana had told doctor’s and staff at GBH, which was subject to doctor to patient privilege, had convinced them not to have her admitted to Kenmore, directly. That informa - tion was not available to the police investigating the matter, or me , at least until the counselling session, which was also subject to doctor to patient privilege . Only Allana and I knew the precise content of the discussions at both hospitals, which included an admis - sion from Allana; that is the way it will stay ! Police Action As expected enquiries surrounding this incident brought my second jobs under immediate scrutiny, I was directed to cease secondary work forthwith , so that was the end of our new home dream , because we didn’t have enough money in the bank. Allana was never really aware how serious this problem was for us, I was facing the sack for many weeks, our medical advisors at Kenmore suggested I keep those matters from her during counselling. That sort of news was negative and would make it very difficult for her to deal with at that time, the hard stuff wasn’t discused. Those matters were addressed much later during counselling sessions at Kenmore but Allana never really listened to the counsellor while I was present, her only concern was
A Story to Remember - 201123
29
moving into our new home . She just didn’t want to know about the other stuff, so lets just forget about it! Medical staff and counsellors from Goulburn Base Hospital and Kenmore Mental Asylum officials formally cleared me of any wrong doing very early in the process, but I still had to deal with our real financial issues outside of counselling sessions. There was more to come when the fact we really were losing the house, finally sunk in, Allana became totally distressed and those one hour sessions became two hours, with more doctors, advisors and counsellors. In those days counselling as we know it now didn’t really exist, counsellors included everybody who talked with us, so over the following weeks I learned about life, awareness of our entitlements, and most importantly, how to work the system so we would not lose the house! When the Police Administration were informed formally of the findings at Kenmore my 1st Class Sergeant pulled me in to his office and we talked. That discussion along with some personal advice, pointed me in the right direction, to get us back on track, we learn new stuff every day if we let it sink in. The counselling sessions at Kenmore continued for the next four or five weeks, with Allana mainly , I waited outside generally but attended a couple of brief sessions, as to be expected, they found nothing medically or mentally wrong with her at all. So we talked and I explained to Allana how our situation really was, if we still wanted to buy our first home I had to keep working extra jobs, but, I had been directed to stop working extra jobs and that was a major problem. I know she had quite a few discussions with Bill Dutallis over the following weeks as he told me he would. Bill, being a saddler, had an easy going manner and talked easily as he worked building new saddles . Allana engaged with Bill easily because she knew horse’s, she had her own horse back in the Wolgan Valley, this was natural progression and she developed a down to earth awareness of what we needed to do. At Bill’s suggestion she decided to go back to work and on days when I was working, so I agreed and she was offered a full time position in one of the larger general stores, similar to Fosseys where she worked at Lithgow. Bill’s wife offered to baby sit Sue-Ellen when I was working and she took on the job, it only lasted a few weeks until she discovered the difficulties arising from working full time, not being around Sue-Ellen and less time for being a mum, she was advised to quit and she did. We had made many new friends during those sessions at Kenmore and Goulburn Base Hospital, real life friends who understood how the system worked, and we kept in contact for many years. Not once, nor at any time did anyone in a position of authority, nor one health official, query our living conditions, or my second jobs as being causal, and neither did I . Not one question, suggestion or discussion as to why or how this happened, from any of the doctors or clinical staff, nobody pressed the issue with minimal follow-up interviews, so we continued on with our lives and that period of our lives was never discussed until 2021.
A Story to Remember - 201123
30
During the following months our Bank Manager guaranteed our deposit, he was raised on a farm and as it so happened I sometimes worked for his father, without being aware of who he was. From that time the house loan was safe and more work came my way, mainly with local farmers who assured me that my bosses would never know . Most of my work was at ( Woodhouselee ) with Ozzie Rabjohn and family, 30kms out of Goulburn and several kilometres off the main road. How did I organise this? The Bank managers father was on the land, Kenmore staffers had connections and contacts and that helped significantly, as did the Catholic orphanage and local farmers with whom I had worked previously, they made it happen for us, because they knew my work ethic. A few weeks later two young offenders broke into the Saddlers unaware that we lived out the back, Allana heard the movement below our bedroom, and we caught one when we burst in through the connecting door into the saddlery. I handcuffed him to a vice in the shop and Allana kept a nervous eye on him while I took off after the other bloke. Unfortu - nately one hundred metres into the chase I lost my pyjama pants and the young bloke got away, here is a newspaper clipping . We didn’t have very much furniture so I decided to build us a wardrobe, because wood - work was my strongest subject at school and whatever tools I didn’t have Bill would lend me. It turned out pretty good really but when we had to move to Gerathy Street we couldn’t get it down the stairs, so we took it out over the large front verandah and onto a two ton flat top lorry, no problem. Different story at Gerathy Street because we couldn’t get it down the hallway and into the front bedroom, so I cut it in half and did a rejoin at it’s new home! Our New Home After we moved into our new home in Gerathy Street Allana sometimes worked hand in hand with the Orphanage, organised through Kenmore, by occasionally having troubled young girls for day visits or to stay with us overnight. We had two runaways from Mel - bourne on one occasion, they came into police custody from the railway station and would have been detained at Kenmore overnight while the police contacted their parent’s in Mel - bourne. However having seen the situation at Kenmore both Allana and I agreed to house both girl’s overnight, regretting their stupidity they both appreciated our offer and both girls sent cards and letters to us over the next cou - ple of years, I still have a letter or card from one, somewhere. Allana’s situation returned to normal very quickly with the help of doctors and staff at Kenmore. A year or so later Sara-Jayne arrived with great interest by staff at Goulburn Base and Kenmore Hospitals, as I dealt with both institutions almost on a daily basis and
A Story to Remember - 201123
31
started many long term friendships, which have continued to this day. I also got more work with local builder Don ‘Dude’ Anabel, a fellow hockey player, golfer and member at Tully Park golf club. Don needed an offsider at that time on a few local projects, he offered regular work and I accepted, as we weren’t in the public eye on any job, so we thought! Don and I were doing modifications to a small factory across road from Tully Park clubhouse one day and I fell between the bearers while working on the factory. I had a very large lump on my forehead which required some explanation at work where I was restricted to station duty for a few days until the swelling on my forehead reduced somewhat. I also worked with ‘Don’ renovating an old homestead about 15km ‘out of town’ on a back road and well back off the road, and one would think I would be safe there, but, my supervising sergeant caught me out as he was driving past, I was working on the roof and he stopped to wave and call out, but all was OK as I was out of town! Along with other cops I did a lot of ‘hay carting’ on properties out around Lake George and Collector where Terry O’Neill was the man in charge at the one man police station, he would organise the work as we always need three workers per team, Terry later moved to Broken Hill while I was stationed there in the early 70’s. I did get some time off to play Hockey with Goulburn Workmens Club on Saturdays during winter and golf very early on Sunday mornings during summer after we got our new house. Occasionally I would take one of the girls out with me for a practice round of nine holes, so I set up a car seat on the golf buggy so they had a good ride. Each one became popular visitor’s to the golf club on weekdays, with a free glass of soft drink after golf. I parred the front nine at Tully Park at different times with each of the girls in the car seat, Sara-Jayne was the last just a couple of weeks before we left for Broken Hill. Policing back in those days was vastly different to now for example at Goulburn Sergeant Kevin McMahon and I were working a Friday night shift patrolling Auburn Street when we came across three young lads yahooing and making lots of noise, we stopped to have a chat and settle things down when Kevin said “I know their parents so lets give these young blokes a bit of a lesson. Get in the back, you lot are going for a ride”. We drove out along a gravel road towards Bungonia and about five kilometres out and we stopped at a bridge over a small creek when Kevin told them to take their shoes off and place them on the corner post’s of the bridge. Under much protest from the young blokes who obviously knew and respected Kevin, we drove them a bit further up the road where he told them to get out and walk back home. More protesting and Kevin said “I’ll be playing golf with your dad in a few hours and I expect to hear about your complaints, from him”! You couldn’t do that these days but Kevin’s idea, and it worked, was to give a warning in this manner, to steer young blokes on a better path and I continued that attitude throughout my career. Bush policing. Goulburn sparked my interest in Forensic Investigation duty due to its involvement in technical examination of crime scenes, plan drawing, accidents of all types, and photogra -
A Story to Remember - 201123
32
phy. Detective Sergeant Bernie Walsh, the person in charge, played a significant role in nurturing my interest. In those days, making an impression on the region superintendent was crucial for career advancement. To further my knowledge in photography, I dedicated some of my days off to working with Bernie. The superintendents’ office conveniently adjoined the Scientific Investigation Section, and we would often have morning tea with the staff, providing valuable networking opportunities. Before transitioning into plain clothes work, an interview in Sydney was mandatory. This interview, known as the Bull Ring, consisted of hardened and highly experienced investi - gating detectives who conducted the assessment. This unique interview format was characterized by its historical significance, showcasing both biases and impartiality that were emblematic of the past, according to the recollections of older detectives. How the interview ran depended on the additional information forwarded from the local OIC of detectives, in my case one very well respected investigator was Detective Sergeant 2/C Gordon Gay, who was small of stature but as tough as nails! I was later to find out he requested I should be given a real hard time, to test me out! I passed the interrogation and true to his word backed me for Scientific duties. We had good neighbours at Gerathy Street, Chris and Cynthia, Neil and Margaret Bool among many others and I continued to work other jobs. The work mostly on farms carting hay, shearing shed rouseabout, building fences, repairing a huge dam on Woodhouselee and clearing areas of land for burning off. This type of work was good for me, it was cash in hand and we could buy furniture or a few little extras to make life a bit easier, etc. Allana was much happier in a proper home, there were no issues, however she wasn’t a sporting person and although she tried to get involved in community groups, that didn’t work out. She wanted part-time work but there were none suitable as she didn’t have any specific skills, work experience or her driving licence. So it was time for Allana to get her licence for mobility and opportunity, so we bought a better vehicle, 1962 Holden Special EK station wagon, no more relying on me to go shopping and Allana had her independence back. Sara-Jayne and Rechelle arrived over the next three years, I commenced Scientific Investigation (Forensic) duty training for a couple of years with Detective Sergeant Bernie Walsh aka The Reverend and it was time for me to look for a full-time crime scene position, as we had been at Goulburn for over four years. Sue-Ellen would soon be starting school, so the time for change was right for the children’s schooling and there was a job going as assistant Scientific Investigator ( Forensic Crime Scene ) at Broken Hill. It was a long way from Lithgow, my application had been approved and Allana was very keen for the move also. We put the house on the market, it took just one month to sell, our furniture was organised to follow us the next week, the station wagon was packed and off we went to the outback.
A Story to Remember - 201123
33
Move to Broken Hill Being very inexperienced travellers we left Goulburn about 1:30pm on 4th July 1972, in the middle of winter, we had no idea about travelling long distances with a family, in a station wagon. It was a big trip with the first leg 530km to Hay across the flat country where neither of us had ever been, we arrived at the motel about 9:30pm, they had a brand new family room that cost us $16.50, plus breakfast. Needless to say everybody slept very well that night, even Rechelle who was a bit shy of twelve months, but generally the girls all travelled well taking in their surroundings along the way. We left earlier the next day as it was another 580km to Broken Hill, so we travelled to Mildura across the Hay Plains, in daylight . Allana couldn’t believe how flat the country was and she took a turn driving for a bit, but after half an hour she handed the wheel back to me as the countryside was pretty flat and not so interesting for the driver. We drove across the state line into Victoria for lunch at Mildura, topped up the petrol tank at Wentworth, then on north up the Silver City Hwy to Broken Hill. We were driving into really heavy head winds and it seemed we might run out of fuel but along came the Coombah Roadhouse for fuel and an ice-cream. At Broken Hill we stayed the first few nights with Allana’s cousins Janette & Rob until the furniture arrived a couple of days later. The flat we had been referred to was a shocker, basically clean but the stove was very dirty despite our heavy cleaning. Very quickly a vertical grill and electric frypan were added to the kitchen appliances, so Allana had something clean to cook with. We didn’t expect this treatment from the landlord who refused to release us from the lease initially, however as we were to find out, Broken Hill was strong union town, so the fight was on. After three weeks of serious pressure from many directions the landlord gave up, the lease was declared invalid , he insisted on certain conditions and it was he who had broken those conditions. Still offering assistance one of the union’s found us a house at 277 Duff Street, Broken Hill South, which became our new address for twelve months, just four blocks from Alma Public School, three blocks to local shops and two and a bit kilometres to Broken Hill’s main shopping centre. Duff Street at South Broken Hill At 277 Duff Street there were three spacious bedrooms, a combined dining room kitchen area, with a living room at the front of the house. Great garden and green house at the rear and a large garage. Oil heating for the winter months, yes it did get a bit cool during winter, but great weather for BBQ’s, of which there were plenty over the four years we were
A Story to Remember - 201123
34
in Broken Hill. Getting hold of some house photo’s is proving difficult, we didn’t have digital camera’s in those days, color negs were sent to Adelaide for overnight processing and all police photos were b&w, which I processed by hand in our dark room at work. I will keep looking! Before taking over from Alec Wightly (aka ‘DA’) at scientific I had to officially attend a six weeks Scientific Investigation and Fingerptint course in Sydney. Although initially very concerned about the length of the course Allana settled in to the new home just fine, she quickly made new friends with neighbours which was good for Allana, although when I arrived back home she was very relieved as she was not used to paying the bills. During the three months I worked with DA we compared our background work experience, personal interests, hobbies and why we got involved in scientific investigation work anyway. DA pointed out the benefits of my overall background work experience skillset, which was vastly different to his! He reckoned I had an advantage that would serve me well in this type of work. DA was supposed to stay six months with me, but he was gone in six weeks because he wanted to get to Newcastle, so I got his early stamp of approval! I completed my six week Scientific Investigation and Fingerprint course in Sydney success- fully, where I impressed the bosses Detective Superintendent Alan Clarke and Detective Sergeant 1/C Jim Merritt with my overall skillset. I am sure Alec had something to do with that because of the way all my one on one interviews went. Detective Sergeant Jack Snowden worked me through my photography and darkroom skills which went without a hitch, so I was glad I had put the extra time into my darkroom skills. Later that year I pleased Jack by taking out first prize in a Broken Hill photo competition, he was so impressed he bought an entire series of Time Life Photography books for all the SIS sections, the older SIS guys will remember those times for sure. Not long after returning home Allana had a medical procedure performed in an Adelaide hospital and a three day stay was required, plus flying to Adelaide and she had never flown before. So here we were again, just the girls and me for three days, this time however the girls were really up for it and they took over house duties. In those early days there was no university course for this job because it was very complex and wide reaching, and it still is. So many different fields of knowledge and expertise that are either useful or essential to our investigation. One incident could involve several fields of expertise such as medical, electrical, mechanical or field engineering, plus many others I was yet to learn about. Not to mention public relations and mining unions, so Broken Hill wasn’t going to be easy and I was about to be introduced to the Barrier Industrial Council (BIC). If we required an expert opinion we had to either bring the expert to the scene or take the relevant parts of the scene to the experts, either way it was expensive and almost impossible to achieve because of budget, time and distance. It was time to innovate as I learned to adapt, my 1960’s my work background and life experience skill’s at that time were very useful to me as a crime scene investigator, because my next job could be anything. In remote areas as a lone investigator travelling all over the
A Story to Remember - 201123
35
countryside I only had personal experience and occasional telephone support to rely on. It never ceased to amaze me as to how much work was out there, but, travel and cost were always a factor, so lots of evidence was never submitted to the labs for examination. Something had to change, as every other day saw something new was popping up within the region, as you will see when I get into the meaty bits of my story. DA warned me about all these issues and said, “good luck”! I didn’t get a lot of crime scene work during the first year outside of Broken Hill and from day one I was expected me to work in the same way as DA did, but within a few months though they came to understand my work ethic a bit better. For example DA had applied for a new drying cabinet to speed up the process of film processing, that was denied on cost grounds. I went directly to Broken Hill public works for assistance and together we built a drying cabinet with timber and fibro sheets, at no cost, and it did the job perfectly. Although I didn’t get to work much outside of Broken Hill and Menindee, Wilcannia was a different kettle of fish, I had plenty of chances out there, so I decided to treat fire with fire and use local expertise, including local farmers and the skills of the old blacktrackers. They taught me a few good methods that have proved extremely useful in other areas throughout my entire service, and that knowledge enabled me to discover new uses, especially the logic. One day while at Menindee attending a local job Terry Picker our stock investigator asked me go to a nearby property and make some enquiries about some wild pig shooters thought to be operating around that property. He warned me the property was big, extending almost to Mungo National Park. When I arrived and talked with the owner (guy with one leg) he believed the same pig shooters were also stealing cattle from neighbouring properties, so he took me out to where he knew they were shooting. We actually spent several hours travelling across his property as he pointed out several sets of vehicle tracks. He had never seen them or their vehicle’s but he was pretty sure it was only one utility or 4WD vehicle. I can’t recall his name, or which property we were on but, he was really switched on because we didn’t use the same property tracks as the shooters, travelling parallel or around. He drew a mud map marking the places we had been to so I could return again the following day, because sunset was fast approaching. The owners wife suggested I was welcome to stay overnight if I wanted to, because I could get an early start in the morning to do my examination of all the tyre tracks and camp sites. A quick phone call to Inspector Errol Green at Broken Hill resolved everything and he gave the OK. Prior to dinner we had a further lengthy discussion with all of the family involved, but they had no idea of what type of vehicle was being used, but they were very interested in how I went about my daily work in general and one of the boys became my personal guide for the next day. The real family chat took place after dinner, it was a large family of grown up children, all
A Story to Remember - 201123
36
living at home and there must have been about ten at the dinner table. They were a bit mystified when I told them I wanted to learn from them while I was out there, so three of the boys ended up tagging along with me just in case we ran into these guys, well that was their story to the ‘old man’ as they wanted to help wherever because of the sheer size of the property. We found tyre tracks on the track leading in through a secondary gate which pointed to both camp sites that were very recent on the property. I managed to make a few plaster cast’s and measured the width of the various tyre tracks which didn’t seem to interest the boys much, pretty dull really, as we didn’t have a vehicle to compare with. This was OK by me at the time because without the son’s taking me back to those places I probably would have got lost anyway! Several weeks later Ray Pickering from Broken Hill detectives had another bloke before the court charged with stealing from local properties, and when they attended court driving a ‘HK’ Holden Station Wagon, things added up. I had found evidence of two foreign vehicles at a couple of camp sites, most likely belonging to the cattle thieves operating in the Menindee-Pooncarie-Ivanhoe & Wilcannia areas, one was a VW Utility, which was identified via the wheel track measurements. Different wheel tracking had been identified on several adjoining properties, the second vehicle was a HK Holden Station Sedan identical to the one belonging to the bloke Ray Pickering had locked up before we com- pared notes, that was really unlucky for them. Not long after I attended a place near Menindee where a fettler working on the rail line had been killed in a tractor accident, things were very different in those days and my attend- ance was requested the following day and the police were the last to be notified about the accident. On arrival I was introduced to the ganger in charge who was none other than Eric Wakefield the same guy I had worked under seven years before. He didn’t remember me and the OIC at Menindee just wanted photographs of the scene and the tractor for the Coroner, any investigation would have been vastly different now. Some time around 1973-74 Terry O’Neill transferred to Broken Hill GD’s from Collector and naturally being old mates we did had the occasional beer, one legendary pub crawl bet ended up at Railway Town pub, which thereafter became the place for us to meet when organising gatherings or the next police BBQ. In Duff St we had a large back yard and a second large well lit shed which was easy to set up for entertaining. So it seemed natural for ordinary and occasional official BBQ’s to be held at the rear of our house in Duff Street, in particular because it was out the south, a few neighbours would be invited as they were always willing helpers and keen to help Allana with salads and stuff. As I was located far away from Sydney HQ, the availability of assistance was extremely limited. Although I could consult with other scientific investigators in different regions for advice, sending exhibits for analysis presented a major obstacle due to the high cost involved. However, Alec Wightly took me to the University of NSW Broken Hill for a general overview, where I had the opportunity to meet up with an old friend and former Lithgowite, Bob Byrne, who worked as a tutor chemist at the university. Alec assured me this was a great place to discuss relevant issues with their specialist teachers, who were always
A Story to Remember - 201123
37
willing to help. After several months, I decided to take things to the next level when Bob Byrne offered assistance with any available scientific resources. He told me to let him know what I needed, and if the matter was serious enough and they could help, they would. As it turned out, Bob Byrne and his team were able to handle two or three small tasks locally, eliminat- ing the need to send them to Sydney for identification. In a few cases when continuity of possession wasn’t required, I would use airline pilots to transport the items to Sydney, where they could be collected at Mascot or handed over directly. This method proved effective for me. I began to rely on local experts to confirm certain issues or establish innocence. Unfortu- nately, I received a reprimand from Sydney HQ for deviating from protocol. The Sydney boss Superintendent Alan Clarke called me to encourage my effort and gave me an ‘A’ for effort and a ‘D’ for not following procedures. Death by Arsenic Poisioning In 1974 I started an investigation a few weeks before the death of Arnold George Mitchell at Fairfield Infectious Disease Ward Melbourne, they believed he was suffering from ‘arsenic poisoning’. He had been treated by Ivanhoe and Wilcannia medical staff and then Broken Hill Hospital, none of which were able to identify what was wrong with George. They sent him to Fairfield Infectious Diseases Hospital in Melbourne after an enquiry by Broken Hill medical staff and ‘arsenic’ got a mention in their response. At that point I was contacted to investigate where or how George could have been ex- posed, so off I went to Wilcannia, Tilpa, Ivanhoe and Menindee and found plenty of trace evidence, analysed by Bob Byrne at Broken Hill university. This project wouldn’t have got started without Bob Byrne because the supply of samples were many and frequent, sometimes days or weeks apart. I had broken the protocol once again to get things done efficiently and nobody challenged me this time, especially once it involved the Homicide Squads from two states when George died, which got the attention of Melbourne Homicide Squad, because things didn’t add up. They contacted Sydney Homicide who sent Detective Sergeant Don McCusker and John Cooke (a class 108 mate) to Broken Hill to talk with Detective Sergeant Peter McLachlan, local detectives and me. We are talking 1974 and the new guy from Broken Hill was utilising new technology by way of Neutron Activation Analysis with ACT Chief Inspector John Goulding to measure the levels of arsenic in his hair samples, now we were in a new world of scientific investigation altogether. This led to testing where George had lived in his caravan, his food, water supply and soil samples from where he had camped. We found arsenic everywhere from Big Ampi to Tilpa, and many campsites in between. Vic Coroner Henry PASCOE - Melb Homicide Harry MORRISON -
A Story to Remember - 201123
38
never resolved but I still have the paperwork - There was another occasion where Allana required urgent medical care at Mildura hospital to have galstones removed, once again the procedure could not be done at Broken Hill and she would be in hospital for a week. So the girls and I took her on another 300Km trip because we had travelled that road before, dropped her off next morning, had some brunch and drove back home, via the half way roadhouse. We did it all again a week later to bring Allana home, which was easier for the girls this time as it meant a stop at the roadhouse both ways. When specialist medical treatment was required we had to travel as we were fairly remote at Broken Hill, but all ended good and the girls were very happy mum was fixed. By now we had learned a fair bit about remote travel, being prepared, etc, and that called for a longer lunch stop at the Coombah Roadhouse on this trip. During 1975 I attended a twelve week Detectives Training course at Redfern which included some very serious physical training, so before I took off we decided to send Allana back home to Lithgow for a week with her family, as life at Broken Hill was totally foreign to our lifestyle. Photo of the three wise monkeys taken while I was on holidays at the hill and Allana had travelled back home for a break, the girls were stressed out! Ha Ha! Why do this! At that time we were still on very low wages, another long road trip was too expensive so a family trip was out of the question. The girls and I were fine and we had a baby sitter organised should I be called out. At Broken Hill I was a lone operator and I was always ‘on call’, 24/7, however the extra money was welcome as the payment of overtime had only just been introduced. Allana didn’t have to worry because the girls looked after me, the bottle you can see on the table contained wine. Kids had gone to bed, it was a hot night and sport was on TV, what more did I need! Packet of chips and the rest is history as Sara-Jayne can explain when she came in to check on me during the night, about 2-3am I awoke and SJ was busy cleaning the carpet beside the bed where I had knocked over the wine bottle and the remaining contents had flowed forth! All three were very happy to see Mum arrive back home safely a week later.
A Story to Remember - 201123
39
By this time the Barrier Industrial Council had Broken Hill mines by the knackers and the police were not allowed to enter the mines for any reason, it wasn’t written down as such but that was the implication and understanding of management, from the way I read the local rules - that was about to change!
A Story to Remember - 201123
40

SIS (1972) Broken Hill

NSW Police Scientific Investigation Section

Advisor: Professor John Shields UNSW

Background:

When I was transferred to Broken Hill Police as a scientific investigator my job was to examine scenes of crime and suspicious or unusual deaths during the early 1970’s. I also assisted police in their every day police duties at many motor vehicle or industrial accident scenes to record what evidence they found via photography, physical collection and scale plans, to assist the courts or other relevant authorities determine what and how had actually happened. Mining was and still is the major industry in Broken Hill, at that time it operated under the influence of unions under the control of the Barrier Industrial Council (BIC). This very powerful union was formed in 1923 by combining eighteen local unions, which also created a strong culture of union militancy among the miners and trade workers within the town, this meant nobody could break union rules, not even the government of the day. Coming from a mining town myself I was fully aware of the union movement and their activities which were normal to me, however I quickly learnt this was not a normal union, everybody had to be a member of a union. The extreme union was answerable to nobody, at least that was their understanding and they even held ‘badge days’ where every member had to wear their union badge on that day or be fined by the union. As I was to discover at Broken Hill police investigations did not always go smoothly where the union or it’s members were involved and there were matters that should have been investigated, but were not, they were handled in-house by the union. Across the board powerful or influential companies, organisation’s, union’s or public utilities with a vested interest in the outcome of any investigation nearly always mean some form of interference which had to be dealth with according to public importance.

What Really Happens:

Around 1972 I was transferred to Broken Hill to take over the local crime scene position, my predecessor spent many weeks passing on local knowledge and introducing me to relevant local connections such as the Department of Mine, North & South Broken Hill Mines, Main Roads, NSW Railway, local news reporters, council staff and president of the BIC Joe Keenan, all of whom I would have to deal with at some time. It was made very clear to me to tread very carefully with the union and I became more aware of the power of the BIC, recognised as the most powerful union in Australia at that
A Story to Remember - 201123
41
time. The union was led by President Joe Keenan who would regularly interfere to protect their members, they were involved in all forms of employment; for some reason that got my attention ! My introduction to that power came about very early on in my time at the hill when the first female police officer to serve at Broken Hill, Connie Dube and her Mum arrived on a Friday not long after my arrival in 1972, it was during summer and her fridge failed that evening. A purely domestic matter that would turn into a significant internal incident for the police administration within hours. On the Saturday morning Connie contacted several service people in Broken Hill and was advised to wait till the following Monday as weekend call out rates involved an initial call out fee, double time and union conditions mandated a minimum hourly rate of four hours, so the cost was prohibitive. She sought advice from police station staff who contacted our Inspector for his assistance as this was a major problem for Connie; all because of Union rules! The ‘boss’ contacted me because he was fully aware of my work background in the electrical industry and refrigeration, so he (Inspector Errol Green) took me to meet Connie and check out her fridge, this was just one cop helping out another. All it needed was a new thermostat, an easy problem to repair so no problem to fix! I went to a local electrical supplier who just happened to be a strong union supporter, he knew who I was, but he wanted to know why I needed the thermostat, which I thought was very unusual, so I simply said “To fix a fridge”! Apparently that was one of the place’s Connie had visited when looking for service, so he couldn’t sell me the part until he had contacted his union, despite the fact I told him I was a qualified refrigeration service technician. The electrical trade union official called Joe Keenan who enjoyed the opportun- ity to demonstrate his influence among his members, and he said “No”! The supplier apologised and said words to the effect, “Sorry I can’t, it’s the union rules and you are not a local”. When I relayed this to Inspector Green he called Joe Keenan about the issue and was also told that any work must be done by a local qualified technician, who was also a union member. So it was a stalemate, but ‘the boss’ and I weren’t going to give up easily on this one! Going back home to dig out my certifications for this quick fix was a waste of time anyway, as I wasn’t a union member. However as I was also the local Police Association Secretary so I requested an urgent formal meeting with the BIC (Barrier Industrial Council) to discuss the situation. Based on ego alone I guessed correctly, this was an invitation Joe could not refuse. Inspector Green agreed and arranged a meeting at his home that morning with the BIC, as expected only Joe Keenan attended. This was an every day matter on a unique occasion for Broken Hill police and Inspector Green didn’t like the direction this issue was going, at the same time he did not want to inflame the situation. Being in a position of authority didn’t apply to us in this situation which we discussed while waiting for the BIC representative to arrive. On arrival Joe Keenan was in an argumentative mood as he pointed out the position of the
A Story to Remember - 201123
42
union rules and there would be no exclusions. Local understanding at the time was that whatever Joe Keenan said was the way business was conducted within Broken Hill, he himself and everyone else in town saw Joe Keenan as the union! This electrical work came within the union rules, and that included the police. Realising the significance of this meeting through my association with many locals within Broken Hill, around the clock, at the hospital, the university, clubs, pubs, on sporting fields and within their homes, I had sound background knowledge as to how the BIC worked. My opinion was that Joe Keenan relied enormously on bluff as he was uneducated and his communication skills were seriously lacking, he could tell you what to do without discus- sion but to me that was all he was capable of, now was the time to test that opinion with some diplomacy, definitely not intimidation. As it turned out my background knowledge was important as we needed to maintain control of the conversation and the situation, which was somewhat delicate. The OIC of Broken Hill Police would be present, I didn’t want to embarrass him so I had to be cautious about what I said, my conduct and how I responded to Joe Keenan’s intimidation. My simple response was, “Joe I am making an easy repair to a refrigerator, which I am qualified to do, and as for the local union rules, they don’t apply to me”. He became even more agitated at this point, setting out how the union worked and who the rules applied to. This explanation only took a couple of minutes, his voice was firm and he insisted I would not be allowed to repair the refrigerator! The inspector said, “Thanks for coming in Paul, you are now aware of the rules, dismissed”. So I left the meeting and returned to the Police Station where a small sealed parcel containing the part I was seeking had been left for me with station staff at the front counter, with an invoice. I repaired the fridge, so the outcome of the meeting was irrelevant, but Joe Keenan didn’t know that, and he never did! The formal ‘dismissal’ apparently satisfied Joe Keenan as the boss later explained and they had a much longer informal chat after I left. Thanks to the manner of Inspector Green, Joe assumed I had been brought into line and he left satisfied. The thermostat for the fridge had been supplied on a personal basis and the supply of the part, as a matter of integrity was never mentioned again!

Social Scene:

I later worked with Joe Keenan many times in a social setting as he was a member of the BIC Band who played at all official functions and send-off’s for police and support staff when their time was up and they left Broken Hill. This was a very amicable arrangement to ensure a good relationship existed, which was very important during those years at the hill.

North Mine Fatality:

On Thursday, the 31st August 1972 at North Broken Hill mine Leslie Thomas Johns, 47, was killed when he fell down a winze - special mine shaft - from the 24th level to the stope below about 11:20am.
A Story to Remember - 201123
43
I was advised of the fatal accident by station staff and requested to attend the scene ASAP by the Broken Hill Coroner Bruce Power, with whom I had a quick meeting and he cau- tioned me there could be some issues. Police had never been allowed underground to investigate mine accidents previously, this situation should never have been allowed to develop. The sudden change will not be well received by the Barrier Industrial Council, so tread carefully and if you have any issues just call me! Alec Wightley had formally introduced me to the Coroner as part of my induction to Broken Hill Scientific Investigation Section and the people I would have to work with. The Coroner took great interest in how I was going to peform in this role, we were in an extremely powerful union town, so it was important that we work together. With no mining experience whatever I was in an awkward situation as to how would I deal with Joe Keenan and the BIC Union, especially if they were obstructive, so I contacted the North Mine management and they recommended I go to their main office on arrival. When I arrived at the North Mine to speak with official’s I was advised my presence was a little unusual as the mines looked after their own incidents and fatalities. Reluctantly the manager took me to the main office where there were four or five senior staff, the shift boss and the BIC Union President Joe Keenan. I was introduced to all and when we got to Joe Keenan he informed the manager we already knew each other. There was nothing to suggest any problems were forthcoming, but that was about to change, very quickly! The manager, shift boss, Joe Keenan and I were still standing and I was told almost immediately that I would not be allowed to enter the mine, as there were Union rules that must be followed. I advised the manager of my position clearly indicating I was there on behalf of the Broken Hill Coroner, to examine the scene, collect any evidence and take photographs as required, that wasn’t a local rule that was the law! That went over his head and Joe Keenan immediately interjected and said words to the effect “The union will not allow the police into the working mine for any reason”. I repeated I was acting on behalf of the Broken Hill Coroner and Joe Keenan said, “We will not allow it, you can’t enter the mine”! I had no mine experience, Joe Keenan knew that and so did North Mine Management, not a word was spoken by anyone for quite some time as they awaited my response. I considered the position and said “Well if that is the case, I will get a warrant from the coroner to enter the mine, if there is any resistance from North Mine or the BIC, I will call for further police assistance”! That was not what they had expected, everyone in the room was stunned at that moment, they had no idea the situation was that serious. At that point both the union and mine had lost control, they didn’t realise the position, management were uncertain and Joe Keenan immediately exploded; “You can’t do that”! I said “Yes I can”! I directed my attention to the mine manager whom I again informed of the warrant, it’s purpose and origin. I addressed all present and indicated there should be no changes or
A Story to Remember - 201123
44
work performed in or around the area of the accident while I returned to the coroner for the issue of a warrant to enter the mine! At that point several heated exchanges developed between Joe Keenan, the shift boss and the manager with the others merely observing and taking it all in. As the arguments settled I asked Joe Keenan to leave the meeting, now! Police presence was not a matter for the union, this was a police investigation and I needed to confer further with mine manage- ment. Joe Keenan and everybody else in the room were further stunned at being dictated to by the Police. Joe Keenan refused to leave the meeting, stating he would contact Inspector Green and have this issue stopped in its tracks, so I said, “Go ahead Joe”. At that point, the manager started to show signs of critical concern, we exchanged glances of understanding and I simply left the building. It was pointless to escalate more direct confrontation between the mine and the BIC. My actions were intended to leave the door open, in an attempt to maintain good relations between mine management and the police, for the foreseeable future. I was about to get a warrant to enter the mine to do my job anyway, and that was all I needed. I wasn’t concerned about gaining entry as I drove back to the coroner’s office, but I did picture myself climbing down fifteen hundred feet on a ladder, with my camera gear and then climbing back up. My first lesson in diplomacy was developing, but I needed to get mine management on-side without the presence of Joe Keenan. Although Joe Keenan was a non-drinker, non-smoker, devout catholic and not well educated, because of his ignorance he was a tough man to talk with. I wasn’t sure about Joe Keenan, I thought I had worked him out, but he was dogged in attitude and his absolute enforcement of union rules. It seems the threat of using police reinforcement to gain entry, by legal means, put considerable doubt in his mind, and the minds of the mine managers who were present. The offence of obstructing the law is in the statutes for a reason. By the time I arrived back at the coroner's office the matter had been settled, Joe Keenan had backed down completely to mine management, the completely unexpected mention of a warrant disturbed the North Mine officials as they had never encountered what they saw as threats from the police before. This was confirmed in a phone call from North Mine management to the coroner, in the presence of Joe Keenan. North Mine management also requested further discussion with me at the mine before I entered to begin my investigation. The coroner agreed and said, “Just do your job Paul, a warrant will not be required, and North Mine will provide any assistance you require”. I was asked by management back at North Mine “If would I agree to a Union representat- ive being with me during my examination”, I agreed without question as any person assisting me would be a union member anyway. The selected union representative happened to be a person I knew personally, and management assured me they would supply any detailed scale plans required for the coroner, which they would hand to me before I left the mine.
A Story to Remember - 201123
45
Because of the distance underground and mine management safety procedures I was fitted out with personal safety gear. I was escorted by five or six other miners including the shift boss, and the work crew involved, who took me to the scene and were very helpful. The shift boss informed me of the entire work process leading up to the accident and escorted me through several levels of the mine to show me how normal work is performed, unions rules and safety procedures all worked during an entire shift. It was the mine manager who handed the plans to me, we shook hands, and I said words to the effect, “Thanks for your assistance, I have not and will not, make any public com- ment”. That is why there is no record of this moment in history apart from written Police records and the Coroners Court. At the post-mortem examination, which I attended, Broken Hill GMO Dr Phil Chapman found the deceased had suffered a fractured skull with extensive cerebral contusions, he had also suffered severe lacerations and abrasions to most parts of his body - these wounds were caused by many steel studs within the metal shaft which were there to break up the ore as it moves through the shaft from one level to the next. A month or so later we had another police send-off, Joe Keenan and the BIC band attended, Joe and I had our usual conversation, no mention of the mine incident was made. Joe and I met many times during the rest of my term at Broken Hill and we never discussed the incident again! Regards Paul R Horton ADipJA PO Box 1060 INVERELL NSW 2360 8 th August 2023 Ref: Stan Goodman (2012),'The Fatal Lodes - Mining Deaths in the Broken Hill District', p.342. © Broken Hill City Council.
A Story to Remember - 201123
46

SIS (1973) Broken Hill

NSW Police Scientific Investigation Section

On 21 September 1973 John Arthur SEMMENS died as a result of injuries received in a ground fall No issues with this investigation - I was invited to become a working member of the Widows Club out south where members complete necessary work at the homes of our lost member! Alec Wightly and his family moved on to Newcastle Scientific Investigation Section but tragedy struck several years later when Alec was involved in an extreme car accident in Sydney, his three children were fatally injured (no mandatory seat belts in those days) which was devestating for Alec and his wife. Obviously he couldn’t handle crime scene work anymore and was transferred to general duties at Hamilton. I moved to Newcastle to replace DA and we had many serious conversations after my arrival, he hadn’t changed on the surface but underneath it was unthinkable. Tibooburra Hotel – Suspicious Death.... One of the most unusual jobs I had while at Broken Hill was at the Tibooburra Hotel where cleaning staff had discovered a middle aged male tenant deceased in his bed one morning after a big night out the previous evening.
A Story to Remember - 201123
47
The job was passed on to me by Peter McLachlan who suggested I leave immediately for Tibooburra, just 330kms on ordinary gravel highway, to examine the hotel room which had been locked up until police from Broken Hill arrived because the death seemed suspicious. Graham Cope from Tibooburra police was away and there was something odd about the death, and so there was; the deceased had been drinking brake fluid! Enquiries at the hotel revealed the deceased was a casual farm hand who had resided at the pub for a few weeks, was in his 40’s and appeared to be in good health. Although he had been drinking quite heavily in the bar the previous evening with several other locals, that was not unusual. There hadn’t been any issues the previous evening in the bar, or indeed during his entire stay, he had simply ran out of cash and there was no obvious explanation as to the cause of death. He had not complained of any illness and was well known to several of the local drinkers who were present that evening. Although he consumed quite a few beers until his money ran out, everything appeared normal when he retired to his room. Examination of the room and his personal belongings appeared normal, apart from the presence of tin of brake fluid, which had been opened and partly used. The publican was very skeptical about the suggestion the deceased had drank brake fluid, the partially used tin of brake fluid was found between the bedside cupboard and the bed, just a tad unusual. The post mortem results confirmed consumption of brake fluid was primary to his cause of death. The Indian Pacific incident: I included this 1973 moment in time because this trans- continental train icon had only been running a couple of years, therefore any incident with the Indian Pacific train, no matter how minor, was important and newsworthy. However that is all it was, a derailment in a slow speed area approaching Broken Hill Railway Station. One of my primary roles was to investigate industrial accidents for the Police and on behalf of the coroner when required, although this was only a de-railment and nobody was injured there had to be an investigation. All the passengers were transferred by bus from the site into Broken Hill.

WRG - Plane Crash

During the early 70’s a wealthy Melbourne business- man had flown out to Broken Hill, with his wife and four other people, to make a very significant contribu- tion to Broken Hill Hospital. They were returning to Melbourne after several days when the aircraft (WRG) got into difficulties in wet and turbulent weather near Pooncarie and crashed into low lying bushland. It took many aerial searches and police three days to locate the crash site which was very difficult to see from the air.
A Story to Remember - 201123
48
In order to reach the crash site ground crews and Police used three 4WD vehicles so they could tow each other out as they got bogged. After reaching the scene it was extremely difficult for search crews to deal with because of decomposing bodies. As the Scientific Investigator from Broken Hill I was flown directly to the scene by helicopter to photograph, examine, record and deal with the identification and removal of the bodies to the Broken Hill morgue. On this occasion volunteers to assist were slow in putting their hands up! The bodies were flown back to Broken Hill by helicopter, three at a time, which meant two trips before the post-mortem examination could begin. I returned to the crash site to retrieve the remaining bodies, which were in an advanced stage of decomposition and during the second return trip, the pilot had to make an urgent landing for respite because of the putrefaction, after this stop we got back to Broken Hill quick smart. Upon returning to the morgue, I discovered all the jewellery had been removed from the first three bodies and placed on a shelf for safekeeping, which made identification more difficult. Being my first major incident I quickly sorted the mess out with the assistance of a local jeweller who was just across the road from the Police Station, then I had to return to the crash scene to complete my examination. Reg Atkinson was the culprit, he unknowingly and apologetically had made a difficult job much easier and he had ensured he and I were now mates for life. Thankfully Reg kept everyone out of my way as the situation became very involved in the following days, all the jewellery and clothing, after being dry cleaned at the local dry cleaners, were matched to their rightful place and all ended well for everybody concerned. After returning to the crash site Sgt Kevin Mason from Wentworth, who was the OIC of the search operation went in search of the remainder of the wreckage, unfortunately I got us lost in the flat country and Maso wanted the compass and he gave me heaps as he was understandably frustrated. … Because we got on well together I refused; ‘This is my job now Maso’ and I was quickly corrected our position with the compass and get us back on track. Then we focused on pinpointing all the major pieces of wreckage until ATA investig- ators arrived to map the scene. Overall, this was a challenging and tragic incident, but with perseverance and teamwork, we were able to fulfil our responsibilities in handling the crash site and the deceased. This is an experience I will never forget because it had it all and when all was done and dusted the families involved went out of their way to say ‘Thank you’, ‘was I OK’ and talk with me about all of the issues involved.

White Cliffs RFDS Lift

A job came in from White Cliffs when a drunken local had assaulted the nursing Sister at the local Hospital, Broken Hill detectives had been notified and the Peter McLachlan passed the job on for my attention. A few quick telephone calls to gather some facts resulted in me accepting a lift to White Cliffs with the RFDS. They were conducting a clinic out there later that day and they would also be checking out the local nursing sister’s
A Story to Remember - 201123
49
condition. All I could take was my camera for weight and storage reasons but a lift with the RFDS would save lots of time and driving, I could complete the job and be back in Broken Hill on the same day. During the flight the pilot was notified about a fire at the local hotel after the assault, and that the nursing sister was OK. There was no serious physical injury to the sister, just minor abrasions and the only blood at the scene belonged to the offender, who ran into the door as the sister guided him back outside of the hospital. This individual was becoming a real problem at White Cliffs and the local police wanted him before the court. After the hospital assault the offender, a local indigenous person, tried to set the hotel alight by setting a fire aginst the main entry to the hotel bar, so this was now an attempted arson and this guy was in trouble.

My Point Is ……

The point of this story is to demonstrate how well everyone within the wider community can work together when required, but this requires co-operation and effort, not demands! Yes I was intimidated by authority early in my career, the senior cops know the rules, comply with policy and procedure or don’t do it at all, if it cost’s too much then leave it! You cannot say that out loud so the public can hear, you cannot blow the whistle and take it to higher authority because you will become a whistle blower and higher authority will then concentrate on you, and not the real issue! I will come back to this ......!

Packsaddle Crash

A grey Morris Mini Panel Van rolled over one day during 1973-74 on the Silver City Highway a few kilometres past Packsaddle Roadhouse, 180km north of Broken Hill on the Sikver City Hwy. There was nothing outstanding about the vehicle had been left beside the road, unattended. I was sent out to investigate and report back to local detectives, on the way out I received information possibly three people had been on board at the time, one was petty criminal Michael Medina and a NZ prostitute, the other was possibly murderer Arthur Joseph Loveday, who wasn’t wanted at that time but was believed to be headed to Tibooburra for a funeral, they were still dangerous so look for weapons and give the van a good check over. I found small blood samples, human and animal hair within the van that was later were later identified as coming from the NZ female druggie and her small dog which travelled everywhere with her. The mini was registered to an associate who was part of a major stolen vehicle investigation at Kogarah and that’s where the connection lay. Apparently they were headed to Tibooburra to attend a funeral which overall was pretty straight forward because it involved a relative of Loveday. Nothing unusual at that time,
A Story to Remember - 201123
50
but, things got very interesting when I was following up on a stolen Holden Torana found 10 or 15km south of Broken Hill on the Silver City highway several days later. major investigation - led to uncover stolen Hol/Torana few km south Wentworth SCHwy - led to major stolen veh ring in Sydney - # Menengitis found during port mortem of aboriginal woman from Wilcannia - Dr Phil Chapman - me assisting - told me to STOP & get out - very contagious & fatal if direct exposure. # # White Cliffs RFDS flight gave me a ride out to investigate an alleged arson at the pub and and assault at the local hospital clinic - # Many years later after we were married we visited Lithgow and Darcy’s daughter Tracey was there when Fiona and I stayed overnight at Darcy’c place in Inch Street, she remembered because Fi made her a very special porcelain doll. I had forgotten about that part but Tracey didn’t and neither did Fiona - there was a fire and the doll was burnt and Trace didn’t think to recover the remnants. Maybe we should all make a better effort at keeping contact! # White Cliffs RFDS flight gave me a lift out there as I had to investigate an alleged arson at the pub and and assault on Sister at the local hospital clinic by indigenous person - # Newcastle work was a different ball game as call outs were many times more frequent than BHill, attending several crime scenes in one night, murder, fatal accidents, industrial accidents, arsons, etc, and although the area was much smaller there were many more towns and populated areas in between - # Result of this was Allana PUSHED very HARD for me to go back to GD’s - this was in the first six months at Newcastle and the more I was called out at night the more persistent she was that I quit - I could never go back after all the work I had put in to get here!
A Story to Remember - 201123
51
A Story to Remember - 201123
52